Bill C-296 would enact the proposed Non-regression of Environmental Protection Laws Act and amend the Auditor General Act, the Interpretation Act and the Building Canada Act. Its stated goal is to apply a principle that environmental laws and regulations should not regress, but should continuously improve in light of scientific and technical knowledge.
The federal Environment Minister would have to create an analysis of whether environmental laws, regulations and policies follow that principle, and provide federal departments and agencies with directions, tools and training to use it.
Federal departments and agencies would have to report to the Minister each year on their use of the analysis, its results and possible improvements.
For bills introduced by a minister or other Crown representative, the Minister would have to table a statement on potential environmental effects and whether the bill is consistent with the principle. If the Minister considers it inconsistent, the statement must explain why.
The Minister would have to review proposed regulations under Acts listed in a schedule. If the Minister considers one inconsistent, it would face a parliamentary tabling and motion process; either House adopting a motion against it would prevent the regulation from being made.
The Interpretation Act would direct that Acts and regulations be interpreted in line with the principle. The bill would also assign review duties to the Commissioner of the Environment and Sustainable Development.
Before recommending an order under the Building Canada Act, the Minister would have to be satisfied the project would follow the principle. The bill would repeal section 19 of that Act, but the supplied material does not show what that section currently does.
These are proposed changes, not provisions shown as in force. The supplied material does not state whether the bill has passed or when it would start.
Federal departments and agencies: They would have to use the analysis and send annual reports to the Environment Minister.
Ministers proposing bills: They would have to arrange for an environmental statement to be tabled for each bill introduced by a minister or other Crown representative. The statement informs Parliament and the public; the bill does not say an inconsistent bill cannot proceed.
People affected by proposed regulations: For regulations under Acts on the schedule, an unfavourable assessment would trigger tabling in both Houses. A motion signed by at least 15 senators or 30 MPs could lead to a vote. If either House adopts the motion, the regulation must not be made.
Projects under the Building Canada Act: The Minister could not recommend an order unless satisfied the project would follow the principle. The supplied material does not identify which projects this condition would cover.
General public: The Commissioner’s report on the Minister’s annual report would be made public one business day after being tabled in both Houses. The bill does not directly create a personal benefit, tax, fee or fine.
The bill does not define the central test of “regression,” leaving room for different judgments about whether a change is consistent with the principle.
The bill requires statements on bills, but does not require an inconsistent bill to be withdrawn or stopped.
The regulation process applies only to Acts on the schedule; that schedule is missing from the supplied material, so its coverage cannot be assessed.
The Minister’s opinion triggers the special parliamentary process, and the bill does not set out a separate appeal or review process for that opinion.