PresentedPaper451-01353 · Parliament 45

Close the U.S. arms transit loophole

Petitioners ask Canada to impose an immediate, enforceable two-way arms embargo on Israel, end direct and indirect exports, suspend imports from Israeli weapons makers, close the U.S. transit loophole, publish transfer reports, and penalize evasion.

Why we would sign this petition

  • The petition identifies the U.S. transit route as a way Canadian military goods and components can reach Israel without adequate Canadian oversight; closing it would address that concern.
  • A two-way embargo would cover both direct and indirect arms exports to Israel and imports from Israeli weapons makers, matching the petition’s stated scope.
  • Public reporting and penalties could strengthen accountability for transfers through third countries and for companies that evade arms-control obligations.

Why we wouldn’t sign this petition

  • The petition does not define exceptions or explain how the embargo would apply to dual-use goods, leaving its scope and implementation uncertain.
  • Including imports as well as exports extends the policy beyond Canadian arms transfers and may involve trade-offs that the petition does not address.
  • Detailed transfer reporting and penalties would require monitoring and enforcement; the petition provides no implementation or cost details.

The summary and both sets of reasons are AI-generated from the petition and given equal weight. Claims are the petitioners’ own; consult the official record for the full text.

Official petition

PETITION TO THE GOVERNMENT OF CANADA TO CLOSE THE ARMS EMBARGO LOOPHOLE WHEREAS civil-society groups have identified the U.S. transfer pathway as a major loophole in Canada's existing export-control system. WHEREAS Bill C-233, the "No More Loopholes Act," was presented as an effort to close this gap, but was voted down in March 2026. We, the undersigned citizens of Canada, call on the Government of Canada to impose a full, immediate, and enforceable two-way arms embargo on Israel, including closing the loophole that allows Canadian military goods and components to reach Israel through the United States without adequate Canadian oversight, and further call on Canada to: 1. End all direct and indirect arms exports to Israel. 2. Close the U.S. loophole for military components, dual-use goods, and parts used in weapons systems. 3. Suspend imports from Israeli weapons manufacturers. 4. Publish transparent reporting on all military goods exported, transferred, brokered, or routed through third countries. 5. Create penalties for companies that evade arms-control obligations.

Government response

No government response is available yet.