City to update street design guidance

Summary#

Edmonton’s Urban Planning Committee directed City staff to review and update the City’s Complete Streets and other relevant guiding documents. The goal is to refine active transportation design standards for network expansion, neighbourhood renewal and other capital projects; the motion does not itself change the standards.

  • Staff are to make bi-directional lanes the preferred on-street facility and set clear conditions for when alternatives would be considered.
  • Staff are to revise the options for combining minimum and constrained standards on existing streets, referring to the Design Domain concept, the Design Exception process and community values.
  • The motion was moved by Councillor Janz and carried 4–0.

What it means for you#

  • People who walk, cycle or use other active transportation: The motion does not immediately change street designs or guarantee a particular facility. It directs staff to update the guidance used for future projects.
  • Residents and communities near future projects: Community values are to inform decision-making, but the motion does not set a public-engagement process or say how those values will be weighed.
  • City staff and capital projects: Staff must review and update the relevant guidance. The motion does not set a deadline or say whether the updates need further approval.

Money#

No cost information is available in the supplied material.

  • The motion directs staff to do the review and update, but gives no cost, staffing estimate or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • When the review and updates must be completed.
  • What “minimum” and “constrained” standards mean, and how they may be combined.
  • What conditions would justify using an alternative to a bi-directional lane.
  • How community values will be gathered or weighed, and whether the updated documents will return to Council.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the motion is that naming bi-directional lanes as the preferred on-street option could make guidance more consistent across City projects.
  • Requiring clear conditions for alternatives could make it easier to understand why a project uses a different design.
  • Referring to design exceptions and community values could allow the guidance to account for constraints on existing streets and local priorities.

Case against#

  • A possible trade-off is that making one facility the preferred option could steer project choices before the street’s specific conditions and other design options are assessed.
  • The motion does not define the standards or set criteria for exceptions. Until staff update the guidance, it is unclear how consistently different projects would apply the direction.
  • The motion does not specify how communities will take part or how their values will affect design decisions.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 3070003

    Passed4 members voted

    Urban Planning Committee, item 10.1 (Complete Streets Review and Active Transportation Design Standards (M. Janz)): That Administration undertake a review and update of the Complete Streets and other relevant guiding documents to refine active transportation design standards for Active Transportation Network Expansion, Neighbourhood Renewal, and other relevant capital programs, including:  1. Standardizing bi-directional lanes as the preferred on-street facility, with clear parameters for when alternatives wou…

    FOR · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    4For

    • Independent4

    0Against