Arts education mapping task force

Summary#

HCR-162 is a Hawaii House concurrent resolution; it does not amend an existing Act. It asks the Hawaii Youth Symphony’s president and CEO to convene a task force to survey arts and arts education providers and create a statewide database and map. Its stated goal is to help people identify where arts programs are available and where access may be limited.

  • The requested task force would include named arts, education, government, and data representatives, plus other people invited by its chair.
  • It is asked to survey public and private schools, municipal services, nonprofits, and private businesses involved in arts or arts education.
  • It is asked to create and maintain a database and public map, identify barriers and underserved areas, and recommend how arts data should be collected and shared.
  • The dataset is to describe availability and location, not measure programs’ quality, outcomes, or effectiveness.
  • The task force is asked to report on music and dance before the 2028 session, then on arts and arts education generally before the 2030 session.

What it means for you#

  • Arts and education providers: The task force is asked to survey organizations like yours. The resolution does not require you to answer or give it information.
  • Students and families: If the requested work is done, a public map could show where arts programs are available. The resolution does not create a new arts service or guarantee that more programs will be offered.
  • The Hawaii Youth Symphony’s president and CEO: The resolution requests that this person convene and chair the task force.
  • Other named members: They are requested to serve or provide representatives. The resolution does not set out a process for choosing the neighbor island program representative.
  • Public: The map is requested to be publicly accessible, but the resolution does not set rules for what information it will show or how it will be kept up to date.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution requests staff work to conduct a survey, build and maintain a database and map, and prepare reports, but gives no budget or staffing estimate.
  • It does not specify who would pay for the work or authorize a particular amount of spending.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied status labels the resolution “signed into law,” but the text itself is a concurrent resolution that requests actions; it does not state those actions as mandatory duties.
  • The text does not say how the task force would collect information, ensure responses, or protect any sensitive information.
  • It does not define “comprehensive,” “underserved areas,” or “equitable access.”
  • It does not specify who would host or maintain the database and map, how often they would be updated, or how long they would remain available.
  • It does not explain how task force members would be selected beyond the named roles and the chair’s invitation of additional people.

Case for#

  • A statewide survey and map could make it easier to see where arts programs exist and where access may be limited.
  • The requested task force brings together arts, education, government, and data representatives, which could help combine information from different settings.
  • Limiting the dataset to descriptive information could help map availability without rating or ranking programs.
  • The requested reports could give lawmakers information and recommendations to consider, including proposed legislation.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not require providers to respond, so the survey may not capture all programs or locations.
  • It requests a database and map but does not provide funding, staffing, or a clear plan for maintaining them.
  • The resolution does not set standards for data quality, privacy, or how gaps in the information would be reported.
  • A map of program availability would not, by itself, show program quality or outcomes; the resolution expressly excludes those measures.