Group to study agri-tourism rules

Summary#

HCR-188 is a concurrent resolution asking the Hawaii Tourism Authority (HTA) to convene a temporary Agricultural Tourism Working Group. Its goal is to recommend ways to encourage agricultural tourism while keeping agricultural land primarily in productive agricultural use. The resolution has passed the House; the supplied material does not show whether the Senate has acted.

  • The requested group would examine existing state and county laws and ordinances relating to agricultural tourism and recommend possible changes, including proposed legislation.
  • The requested members are the HTA’s president and CEO or a designee, who would chair; the state Board of Agriculture and Biosecurity chair or a designee; one representative from each county selected by its mayor; and representatives of the Hawaii Farm Bureau and Hawaii Farmers Union.
  • The chair is requested to invite representatives from the coffee, cacao, macadamia nut, and floriculture industries, as well as any others the group considers necessary.
  • The group is requested to report to the Legislature at least 20 days before the 2027 regular session and to dissolve by June 30, 2027.
  • The resolution does not change agricultural-tourism rules, permits, or land-use laws. It asks for a review and recommendations.

What it means for you#

  • Farmers, ranchers, and agricultural-tourism businesses: No permits, activities, or land-use rights change under this resolution. The group may recommend future changes, but those would require further action.
  • HTA and named agencies and organizations: The resolution requests their participation in the group. It does not set out a funding amount, staffing requirement, or process for carrying out the review.
  • Counties and invited industry representatives: County mayors would select county representatives if the group is formed. The chair is requested to invite the named industry representatives; the resolution does not require them to participate.
  • Public: The resolution does not create a new public service or a process for residents to apply, appeal, or comment.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution specifies no appropriation, cost estimate, or number of staff.
  • If the group meets and prepares a report, members and agencies may have to spend time on that work; this is an inference, and the resolution gives no cost.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not define “agricultural tourism” or set criteria for deciding which activities count.
  • It does not specify how the group should review laws, gather public input, reach recommendations, or handle disagreements.
  • It does not say whether the group’s meetings or report must follow any particular public process.
  • The resolution requests the group and its work; it does not explain what happens if HTA or a requested participant does not take part.
  • The supplied status does not show whether the Senate has acted on the resolution.

Case for#

  • The resolution describes differing county processes and interpretations of state rules. A joint review could identify where rules conflict or are unclear.
  • A group with state, county, farm-organization, and industry representatives could bring several perspectives to recommendations.
  • Reviewing how to support farm income while keeping agricultural land in productive use could help lawmakers consider both aims before changing laws.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not define agricultural tourism or give the group standards for balancing tourism activity with productive agricultural use, so its recommendations may leave key questions open.
  • It sets no required public-input process, detailed review method, or follow-up plan for the recommendations.
  • The group is requested, not required, and the resolution does not provide funding or staff. Its work and recommendations may therefore depend on available time and resources.