Tax reporting study analyzes corporate income

Summary#

HCR 189 is a concurrent resolution requesting an analysis; it does not create or amend a tax law. Its goal is to give lawmakers information for long-term fiscal planning, without deciding in advance whether tax rules should change. The House has passed it, but the supplied material does not show Senate concurrence.

  • If adopted, it would request the Department of Taxation to analyze corporate income reporting, including how foreign subsidiary income is treated.
  • The requested analysis would estimate tax revenue linked to corporations with foreign subsidiaries and compare possible revenue effects under separate entity, water’s-edge combined, and worldwide combined reporting.
  • It would also examine how different tax-base definitions fit with Hawaii’s current apportionment method (how income is assigned among jurisdictions), and consider administration, compliance costs, and enforcement.
  • The Department is asked to compare other states’ approaches and publicly available outcomes, and identify data limits, assumptions, and implementation challenges.
  • The Department is asked to report to the Legislature no later than 20 days before the 2027 Regular Session. The request is limited by what is practicable and taxpayer-confidentiality protections.

What it means for you#

  • Corporations and taxpayers: The resolution would not itself change tax rates, tax bills, filing duties, or the treatment of corporate income. It requests an analysis, not a change to tax rules.
  • Department of Taxation: If the resolution is adopted, the Department would be asked to do the analysis and submit the report by the stated deadline. The resolution does not say the Department must carry it out.
  • Legislators and the public: The requested report could provide information for later decisions, but the resolution does not require lawmakers to act on it or propose any particular tax change.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of the requested analysis.

  • The resolution requests work by the Department of Taxation but does not specify funding, staffing, or a spending limit.
  • It asks for estimates of possible tax revenue under different reporting models; it does not change tax revenue or direct that any model be adopted.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not set out a detailed method for estimating revenue or comparing economic outcomes.
  • The meaning and scope of “corporations with foreign subsidiary structures” are not specified in the text.
  • The report is limited to what is practicable and consistent with taxpayer confidentiality; how much data will be available is not stated. The Department is asked to identify data limits.
  • The resolution does not set a process for follow-up or require any tax-policy decision after the report.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the resolution is that comparing reporting systems could help lawmakers judge how different rules might affect revenue and forecasting.
  • The requested review includes administrative feasibility, compliance costs, and enforcement, not just possible revenue gains.
  • Requiring the report to identify data limits and assumptions could help readers understand how reliable its estimates are.
  • The resolution asks for analysis without committing in advance to a tax change.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the resolution does not provide funding or staff for the requested work, or require the Department to complete it.
  • Comparisons may be limited if confidential or unavailable data prevent reliable estimates; the resolution sets no minimum level of detail.
  • The report could leave lawmakers with options but no direction on which, if any, should be adopted.