Waste-reduction group to study deconstruction reuse

Summary#

H.R. 148 is a proposed Hawaii House resolution, not a bill that changes state law. It asks the Office of Planning and Sustainable Development (OPSD) to convene a Demolition Waste Reduction Working Group; its stated goal is to reduce construction and demolition waste and support reuse. The supplied status says it is at the introduced stage and was referred to Finance; it is not law.

  • The resolution requests that OPSD’s director or designee chair the group, with the Comptroller or designee also included.
  • It requests invitations to private-sector representatives from construction, demolition and deconstruction, reuse retail, real estate development, historic preservation, architecture, urban planning, and waste management.
  • It asks the group to invite and involve community groups with expertise in workforce development, public policy, and environmental justice.
  • It requests work on identifying and implementing waste-reduction solutions, scaling deconstruction and materials reuse, encouraging public-private collaboration, aligning with state goals, and developing a framework for policy and economic incentives.
  • It requests annual reports to the Legislature, including findings, recommendations, proposed legislation, successes, and further opportunities.

What it means for you#

  • State government: OPSD is asked to convene and chair the group, and the Comptroller is asked to participate. These are requests in a resolution, not binding duties created by law.
  • Businesses and community groups: The chair is asked to invite specified industry representatives. Community groups with the listed expertise are to be invited and involved. The resolution does not require any organization to join.
  • Residents: The resolution does not itself change landfill rules, require deconstruction or material reuse, create incentives, or change anyone’s rights or costs. Any such proposals would need further action.
  • The public generally: The stated concerns about landfill pressure and environmental impacts explain the resolution’s purpose; the resolution does not guarantee those problems will be reduced.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution requests a working group and annual reports, but gives no spending amount, staffing level, or funding source.
  • It asks the group to develop a framework for possible incentives; it does not itself create or fund incentives.

What is unclear#

  • Because the resolution requests action rather than requiring it, it is unclear whether or when OPSD would convene the group.
  • The resolution does not set a deadline to form the group, a final end date, or a process for choosing invitees.
  • It does not specify how the group would make decisions or what “identify and implement solutions” would involve.
  • It does not explain how community groups would be involved or how their input would affect recommendations.
  • It requests annual reports but does not specify how long reporting would continue or what happens if a report is not submitted.

Case for#

  • The resolution identifies construction and demolition waste as a source of landfill pressure and says a coordinated approach could help address it.
  • A group with government, industry, and community participation could bring different expertise together before proposing policy changes.
  • Studying deconstruction and reuse, and considering incentives, could help identify options without imposing new requirements through this resolution.
  • Annual reports could give lawmakers findings and recommendations to consider.

Case against#

  • The resolution requests, but does not require, OPSD or other participants to act. The group and its work are therefore not assured.
  • It does not provide funding, staffing, decision rules, or deadlines for forming the group, which could limit or delay its work.
  • The resolution asks for strategies and a framework but does not set measurable targets or say how proposed solutions would be assessed.
  • The group’s proposed industry representation is detailed, but the resolution does not explain how community groups would be selected or how their views would be weighed.