Study on algorithmic discrimination law reach

Summary#

SR-165 is a Hawaii Senate resolution titled “Requesting The Hawaii Civil Rights Commission To Examine The Applicability Of Existing State Anti-discrimination Laws To Algorithmic And Automated Decision Systems.” It does not amend those laws; its goal is to assess how they apply to such systems and report possible next steps.

  • The resolution requests that the Hawaii Civil Rights Commission examine whether existing state law gives it enough authority to investigate and remedy discrimination involving algorithmic or automated systems.
  • It asks the Commission to identify possible jurisdictional and evidentiary challenges, and consider whether guidance, rulemaking, or administrative clarification would help.
  • It asks the Commission to consider whether an intake or complaint pathway is feasible under existing law. It does not establish one.
  • The Commission is requested to report its findings and any recommendations, including proposed legislation, no later than 20 days before the 2027 regular session.

What it means for you#

  • People who believe an algorithmic or automated system discriminated against them: The resolution does not create a new right, complaint process, or remedy. It asks the Commission to study whether existing laws apply and whether a complaint pathway is feasible.
  • Businesses and other organizations using these systems: The resolution does not impose new duties or penalties. It asks whether guidance or other clarification may help explain existing responsibilities.
  • Hawaii Civil Rights Commission: The Commission is requested to conduct the examination and submit a report. The resolution does not specify how it must conduct the study.
  • General public: The resolution does not itself change anti-discrimination protections or require anyone to use, disclose, or stop using an automated system.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution gives no spending amount or funding source. It requests an examination and report, but does not say what staff time or other resources they would require.

What is unclear#

  • The text of the state anti-discrimination laws is not supplied, so their current coverage and the Commission’s existing authority cannot be verified here.
  • The resolution does not define “algorithmic” or “automated” decision systems.
  • It does not set a study method, consultation process, or required level of detail. The requested examination is “to the extent possible.”
  • It is unclear whether the Commission will recommend a complaint pathway, new rules, or legislation; the resolution asks it to consider these matters, not to adopt a particular solution.

Case for#

  • The study could clarify whether existing protections cover discrimination involving automated decisions, without changing people’s rights before that question is examined.
  • Identifying jurisdictional and evidentiary challenges could help show where investigations or claims may be difficult.
  • Considering guidance and a possible complaint pathway could help people and regulated organizations understand how existing law applies.
  • The report could give lawmakers specific options to consider before making changes to the law.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not itself address any alleged discrimination or change available remedies; any change would depend on later action.
  • It requests a study but does not set out a method, required consultations, or detailed standards for the Commission’s work.
  • A study and report may require staff time, but the resolution provides no cost estimate or funding.
  • It is unclear whether the Commission’s recommendations, if any, would lead to clearer rules or a workable complaint process.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1676307

    Passed5 members voted

    Senate Judiciary: Passed, Unamended

    FOR · 5

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    5For

    • Democratic4
    • Republican1

    0Against