Religious land housing rule bypasses zoning

Summary#

House Bill 937 would add a new section to Idaho’s Local Land Use Planning Act; it does not amend any other law in the supplied text. Its goal is to set rules for multifamily and mixed-use development on qualifying religious land. The bill has been introduced but is not law.

  • Cities would have to allow multifamily and mixed-use development on qualifying religious land without requiring a zoning change, variance, conditional use permit, or other special approval.
  • A city would have to approve a qualifying application if it meets the other applicable rules; approval would be ministerial (based on whether the rules are met, not a discretionary choice).
  • Cities could not limit buildings to three stories or fewer, but could limit buildings above three stories.
  • These rules would not apply to religious land within one-quarter mile of a heavy industrial use, airport, or military base.
  • Developments would remain subject to generally applicable sewer, water, stormwater, and building-code rules. The bill would also require regular property taxes and rule out a specified property-tax exemption.
  • The rules would apply to applications received on or after July 1, 2026. The bill says it would take effect on that date.

What it means for you#

  • Religious organizations and developers: The rules cover land owned by a nonprofit religious entity organized primarily for religious purposes, or land it leases for at least 40 years. Multifamily means at least three dwelling units. Mixed-use means residential and nonresidential uses, with residential uses making up at least 65% of the development’s total square footage.
  • Religious organizations and developers: If the land and project qualify, the city could not require a zoning change or special approval. The project would still need to meet other applicable regulations, including the listed infrastructure and building requirements.
  • Cities: A city would have to allow and approve qualifying projects that meet applicable rules, subject to the bill’s limits on approval requirements and building-height restrictions. It could not require an existing building to be converted to standards above the otherwise applicable international building code standards.
  • Cities and residents: The bill does not cover homeless shelters. It says it does not require approval of homeless-shelter permits and does not limit a jurisdiction’s ability to regulate or prohibit them.
  • Taxpayers: Housing developments under this section would be subject to regular property-tax laws and could not use the property-tax exemption cited in the bill.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material; no publicly available information on likely total costs is provided.

  • The bill requires cities to process qualifying applications, but gives no estimate of city staffing or other costs.
  • It provides no estimate of development costs or tax revenue. It specifies that covered housing developments would be taxed under regular property-tax laws and would not qualify for the cited exemption.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current text of Idaho’s Local Land Use Planning Act or the cited tax law. I could not verify which current rules would change or how the tax exemption works under current law.
  • The bill does not set a deadline for city decisions or describe an appeal process.
  • It does not explain how conflicts between this section and other local rules would be resolved beyond the rules it specifically limits.
  • “Heavy industrial use” is defined by reference to hazardous conditions or effects such as odors, noise, or fumes, but the bill does not explain how a city would decide whether a particular use meets that definition.
  • The bill does not provide a cost estimate, funding source, or reporting requirements.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would make it easier to build homes on some religious land by removing zoning changes and other special approvals for qualifying projects.
  • Requiring approval when a project meets applicable rules could make the decision less dependent on a city’s discretion.
  • The bill keeps general sewer, water, stormwater, and building-code requirements in place, while excluding sites near certain industrial, airport, and military uses.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill limits cities’ ability to use zoning and other special approvals to decide whether these housing projects fit local plans.
  • The bill does not set decision timelines or explain how disputes over eligibility or applicable rules would be handled.
  • It is unclear how much city staffing or other public cost would be needed to process applications under the new requirements.