HOA to JOA conversion

Summary#

H-963 would amend Idaho law on homeowner’s associations (HOAs) and add rules for a new type of association called a joint ownership association (JOA). Its stated goal is to move HOAs toward associations focused on shared property; it does not guarantee that result for every association. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • HOA boards would have to hold open meetings, keep meeting minutes for at least 10 years, and hold a membership meeting each calendar year. The bill also sets rules for closed meetings, meeting notices, conflicts of interest, and quorum.
  • HOAs at least 10 years old on January 1, 2027, would convert to JOAs on January 1, 2030, unless members vote against conversion. Younger and later-created HOAs would face conversion after 10 years.
  • Before conversion, an HOA would have to hold a meeting and provide a plan describing the proposed JOA documents and the effects of conversion, including the transfer of assets and liabilities.
  • A JOA could assess owners for actual and reasonable costs of maintaining and managing common property, insure that property, and make related contracts. It could not regulate conduct unrelated to common property or set aesthetic standards.
  • On conversion, association powers to regulate matters beyond common property would end, while terms needed to preserve common easements and maintenance duties would remain unless amended.

What it means for you#

  • HOA members: You would have to receive notice of a meeting about a proposed conversion. If a quorum is present and a majority of the votes represented and voting oppose conversion, it would not happen then. Otherwise, the bill says the HOA converts. Members could vote against conversion again every 10 years.
  • Homeowners in a converted association: The JOA’s authority would focus on shared property. Restrictions giving the association authority over other matters would end, subject to the bill’s exception for terms needed to preserve common easements, maintenance duties, and related matters.
  • HOA boards: The proposed rules require open meetings, minutes kept for 10 years, and annual membership meetings. Members could attend through a representative named in a signed writing. A majority of members would have to approve electronic or hybrid annual meetings.
  • People in unincorporated HOAs: The bill would require bylaws covering meetings, notices, minutes, fee changes, and other listed matters. Those bylaws would have to require a majority of all members to approve fee or assessment increases.
  • Homeowners generally: The bill does not itself impose a state tax, create a direct homeowner benefit, or transfer a homeowner’s individual property. It provides for transferring association assets and common property to a JOA.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not provide an estimate for public spending or for the cost of conversion.
  • A JOA could collect assessments only for actual and reasonable costs of maintaining and managing common property. It could also obtain insurance and enter related contracts.
  • The bill does not state how much assessments might be, or how conversion would affect any particular homeowner’s payments.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the Idaho laws being amended was not supplied. I could not verify which HOA rules already exist and which would change.
  • The bill does not explain how conversion votes work if there is no quorum, or set detailed voting, challenge, or appeal procedures.
  • It does not define “actual and reasonable” costs, or explain how disputes over common property or JOA authority would be resolved.
  • The bill requires a conversion plan but does not set a standard form, review process, or deadline for completing the transfer.
  • The bill does not explain how conversion would interact with existing HOA contracts, debts, or restrictions beyond the rules it specifies.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that HOA authority should be limited to shared property, rather than extending to residents’ conduct or property matters unrelated to that shared property.
  • Annual meetings, open board meetings, long-term minute keeping, and member notice could give homeowners more ways to understand and take part in association decisions.
  • Requiring a conversion plan could give members information about proposed governing documents and asset transfers before a vote.
  • The bill allows members to oppose conversion, rather than making it unavoidable at the first scheduled conversion date.

Case against#

  • One concern is that conversion is automatic unless enough members vote against it. The bill does not clearly explain the outcome if a meeting lacks a quorum.
  • Ending association authority over matters beyond common property could disrupt existing rules or arrangements; the bill does not spell out how every existing restriction or agreement would be treated.
  • The bill requires transfers of assets and liabilities but gives limited detail about resolving disputes or handling complex obligations.
  • The bill sets new meeting, recordkeeping, and conversion requirements without estimating the costs to associations or homeowners.