SNAP would restrict candy and soda

Summary#

House Bill 938, an act relating to public assistance, would amend Idaho Code section 56-275, which concerns a waiver to limit candy and soda purchases through SNAP. Its stated goal is to enhance nutrition by asking the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to let Idaho exclude those foods from eligible purchases. The bill is at the introduced stage, so it is not law and passage is uncertain.

  • The bill sets out categories that are not “candy,” including flour-containing or refrigerated items, baked goods, savory snacks, fruit snacks made with real fruit, trail mix, several kinds of bars, and baking ingredients.
  • It sets out categories that are not “soda,” including drinks with milk or milk substitutes, drinks that are more than 50% juice, drinks needing preparation, sports drinks used for hydration, oral rehydration solutions, and products made as necessary nutrition or dietary supplements.
  • The state health and welfare director must ask USDA for a waiver to exclude candy and soda from SNAP-eligible foods. If USDA refuses, the director must ask again each year until it is granted.
  • If USDA grants the waiver, the director must prohibit using SNAP benefits to buy candy and soda as defined in the law.

What it means for you#

  • Idaho SNAP recipients: The bill would not immediately prohibit candy or soda purchases. That prohibition would apply only if USDA grants the waiver. If granted, the bill’s definitions would determine which products are covered.
  • Idaho Department of Health and Welfare: Its director would have to request the waiver and, if refused, renew the request annually.
  • Retailers: If the waiver is granted, the purchase prohibition would affect what SNAP benefits can be used to buy. The bill does not set out retailer procedures.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not directly change taxes, SNAP benefit amounts, or eligibility for SNAP.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the director to request a waiver, but gives no estimate for staff time or other costs.
  • It provides no appropriation, fee, fine, or estimate of savings or lost revenue.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of Idaho Code section 56-275 was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which parts of these definitions are new and which already apply.
  • The bill does not explain how the state or retailers would classify products that may fit more than one category.
  • “Necessary nutrition” is not defined, and the bill gives no decision process for disputed products.
  • It does not set a date for USDA to decide, beyond requiring another request each year if the waiver is denied.
  • The bill does not explain how SNAP recipients or retailers would be told about any resulting purchase limits.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let Idaho seek limits on SNAP purchases of candy and soda, while keeping listed foods and drinks outside those definitions.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that it targets specified product categories rather than changing SNAP eligibility or benefit amounts.
  • The annual request duty means the state would keep seeking the waiver if USDA initially refuses it.

Case against#

  • The purchase restriction depends on USDA granting a waiver, so the bill itself does not ensure that the restriction will take effect.
  • Some exclusions use terms the bill does not define, such as “necessary nutrition.” That could leave uncertainty about which products qualify.
  • The bill gives no cost estimate or detailed process for applying the definitions, which could make implementation harder to assess.