Rule editing power moved to legislative office

Summary#

House Bill 941 would amend Idaho’s Administrative Procedure Act and repeal a section of that law on periodic review of administrative rules. It moves the Office of the Administrative Rules Coordinator from the Division of Financial Management to the Legislative Services Office; its stated goal is not given in the supplied material.

  • The Legislative Services Office director would appoint the coordinator, who would serve at the director’s pleasure.
  • The office would remain an office within an existing agency, not a new independent body. Its employees would be nonclassified and exempt from the cited state personnel rules.
  • The coordinator would set a uniform style, form, and numbering system for agency rules, review submitted rules for compliance, and could return rules that do not comply.
  • The supplied bill text appears to replace a limited power to make clerical corrections that do not change a rule’s meaning or effect with authority to make changes to proposed and existing rules before publication. The bill’s formatting is lost in the supplied text, so the exact wording and scope cannot be verified.
  • The bill would repeal the section of law concerning periodic review of administrative rules. The supplied material does not include that section’s requirements.
  • The bill declares an emergency and would take effect upon passage and approval. It is introduced, so it is not law and passage is uncertain.

What it means for you#

  • State agencies: They would continue to submit rules for review of style, form, and numbering. The coordinator could return rules that fail those standards. The bill’s apparent change to the coordinator’s editing power may affect agencies’ rules before publication, but its exact reach is unclear.
  • State government: The coordinator’s office would be housed in the Legislative Services Office instead of the Division of Financial Management. The bill does not say whether staff would transfer or how the move would work.
  • People and businesses affected by agency rules: The bill does not directly change any particular rule, benefit, fee, or penalty. Repealing the periodic-review section could change how rules are reviewed over time, but the supplied material does not show what review the current law requires.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill places the office in the Legislative Services Office but gives no staffing number, transfer plan, or cost estimate.
  • It makes no explicit appropriation and does not set a fee or fine.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text’s formatting does not show clearly which words are deleted and which are added in the provision on changes to rules. The scope of the coordinator’s revised power cannot be verified from this text alone.
  • The text of the repealed periodic-review section is not supplied, so the review duties or schedule that would end cannot be described.
  • The bill does not explain how the office, staff, or records would move between agencies, or whether the Legislative Services Office would receive added funding.
  • The bill does not set procedures, timelines, or appeal rights for rules returned by the coordinator.
  • The parent law is not supplied, so the bill’s changes cannot be fully checked against current law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for moving the office is that placing it in the Legislative Services Office could make coordination with the Legislature’s rule-publication work more direct. The bill does not state this as its reason.
  • A common style and numbering system, with the power to return rules that do not follow it, could make rules more consistent to publish and use.
  • If the bill broadens the coordinator’s editing power, supporters could see that as a way to correct problems before rules are published. The bill does not explain what limits would apply.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the apparent broader power to change rules before publication lacks clear limits in the supplied text, especially if changes could affect meaning or effect.
  • Repealing the periodic-review section could remove a regular check on rules. The supplied material does not show what that check currently requires or whether another process would replace it.
  • The bill does not explain how agencies could challenge a returned or changed rule, or how the office would be held accountable for its decisions.
  • Moving the office and assigning it to the Legislative Services Office may require staff or other resources, but the bill provides no cost estimate.