Litigation financing transparency rules

Summary#

House Bill 946 would add a new Chapter 21 to Title 48 of the Idaho Code; it does not amend a named existing Act. Its stated goals are litigation-financing transparency, national security, and consumer protection. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • Litigation financiers would have to register with the Idaho Secretary of State before financing claims in Idaho, provide ownership and management information, and update their registration.
  • The bill would cap a financier’s payment at 25% of the monetary recovery and set contract rules, including a five-day cancellation period and no debt beyond the consumer’s recovery.
  • Consumers or their lawyers would generally have to disclose financing contracts to the other parties and the court or agency handling the claim. The contract and the financier’s participants could be subjects of discovery.
  • The bill would bar foreign adversaries and “foreign persons of concern” from financing claims or investing in, controlling, or affiliating with a litigation financier. It would require certain disclosures about other foreign persons.
  • Violating the chapter would make the financing contract unenforceable by the financier or its successor. In class actions, financiers would owe class members a fiduciary duty (a duty to act in their interests).

What it means for you#

  • Consumers seeking claim funding: A financier would have to give you a complete written contract and make specified terms clear. You could cancel within five days after signing or receiving funds, whichever is later. If the claim brings in no money, you would owe nothing; if the recovery is too small to cover the financier’s fee, you would owe no more than the recovery.
  • Consumers and their lawyers: Unless a court or the parties agree otherwise, the financing contract would have to be disclosed to each party or its lawyer and to the court, agency, or tribunal handling the claim. The contract’s existence and participants could be examined through discovery.
  • Lawyers and parties: A lawyer who is a party to the financing contract would have to give it to the consumer. Parties and lawyers could not share defined “proprietary information” with a financier; parties also could not share it with a foreign person, foreign adversary, or foreign person of concern.
  • Financiers and businesses providing services to consumers: Financiers would face restrictions on referral payments, assignments, legal advice, and influence over claim decisions. Businesses providing goods or services related to a financed claim could not have a financial interest in its financing or receive related payments from a financier.
  • Class-action members: A class member could request a copy of the financing contract from class counsel. The bill would also require disclosure of certain relationships between class counsel and the financier.
  • Taxpayers and public agencies: The bill does not create a new front-line service or change taxes or benefits. The Secretary of State would handle registrations and could set forms and filing fees.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated public or private costs.

  • The bill would authorize the Secretary of State to set registration filing fees, but does not set their amount.
  • It would require registration and disclosures, but does not estimate staffing or compliance costs.
  • Financiers’ payments would be capped at 25% of the monetary recovery.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include current Idaho law on litigation financing, so what rules or protections already exist—and how much this bill would change them—could not be verified.
  • The bill does not set registration fees, identify a specific enforcement office, or lay out a complaint or investigation process.
  • “Foreign person” is defined broadly, including some individuals and entities based on citizenship, ownership, control, affiliation, or location. The bill does not explain how close or indirect a connection must be to count as “affiliated.”
  • “Proprietary information” includes information designated as proprietary by a party or covered by a court order. The bill does not explain how this restriction would interact with other disclosure obligations.
  • The bill does not explain how its rules would interact with existing programs or financing arrangements, including where an exception may apply.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that registration and ownership disclosures could make it easier to identify who is financing claims.
  • Contract rules, a recovery cap, and a cancellation period could give consumers clearer terms and limit what they owe.
  • Barring financiers from directing litigation decisions could help keep control with consumers and their lawyers.
  • The foreign-funding restrictions and class-action duties could address concerns about outside influence and financiers’ responsibilities to class members.

Case against#

  • The bill requires broad disclosures of financing contracts, and permits the contract and its participants to be subjects of discovery. That could expose sensitive information or add cost and work to legal claims.
  • The bill’s broad definitions and restrictions on sharing proprietary information could make it difficult to know which people, entities, or information are covered.
  • The bill allows a contract to become unenforceable for any violation by a financier, but does not set out a process for resolving disputes about whether a violation occurred.
  • Registration, disclosure, and compliance requirements may add costs, but the bill gives no estimate.