Fantasy contests lose licensing and taxes

Summary#

HB 5814, “Sports Wagering-Fantasy Mkt,” would amend Illinois’s Sports Wagering Act and Criminal Code of 2012; it would not create a new law or replacement fantasy-contest program. It would repeal the Act’s fantasy-contest provisions and remove related exceptions in the Criminal Code. The bill is introduced and is not law; its text says it would take effect when it becomes law.

  • Fantasy-contest operators would lose the Act’s dedicated licensing system and the privilege tax tied to those licenses.
  • People who enter fantasy contests would lose the Criminal Code exception that says participants in qualifying contests cannot be convicted of gambling. This could expose some conduct to the general gambling law; the bill does not expressly ban every fantasy contest.
  • The bill would remove the fantasy-contest-specific limits on recovering gambling losses. The general law allows a person who loses at least $50 through gambling to sue the winner; it also allows another person to sue after six months, with a possible judgment of three times the loss.
  • The bill would repeal the exchange-wager transaction tax provision. The supplied text describes that tax as 1.75% per exchange wager, rising to 3.5% after a licensee’s first five million exchange wagers in a fiscal year.
  • The bill does not replace the repealed fantasy-contest rules with a new licensing, tax, or operating system.

What it means for you#

  • Fantasy-contest players: You would lose the specific protection against a gambling conviction for taking part in contests covered by the repealed provisions. Whether a particular contest or activity would violate the general gambling law would depend on how that law applies. The bill does not itself make every fantasy contest illegal.
  • Fantasy-contest operators: You would no longer have the dedicated license and tax system under the Sports Wagering Act. The bill does not say whether other laws would require a license or restrict particular contests.
  • People who lose money in fantasy contests: The bill would remove the fantasy-specific provisions that exclude certain losses from recovery. The general gambling-loss rule may then apply, but how it would apply to a particular contest is not explained.
  • Sports-wagering licensees: The exchange-wager transaction tax would be repealed. The bill does not repeal the other sports-wagering taxes shown in the supplied text.
  • General public: The bill does not establish a new front-line service or a replacement system for fantasy contests.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill repeals the fantasy-contest privilege tax and the exchange-wager transaction tax. No estimate of lost state revenue is provided.
  • The bill does not state whether removing the fantasy-contest licensing system would reduce public costs or require other government resources.
  • The bill does not change the other sports-wagering taxes shown in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how the general gambling law would apply to different kinds of fantasy contests after the specific exception is removed.
  • It does not say whether operators would need approval under another law or what rules would govern contests that continue.
  • It does not explain how the general gambling-loss recovery rule would apply to fantasy-contest losses.
  • The supplied material does not include the full current Acts, so I could not verify the bill’s changes against all current law.
  • No fiscal estimate or information about transition arrangements is provided.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that fantasy contests should not receive a special exception from Illinois’s general gambling law.
  • Removing the dedicated licensing and tax provisions could eliminate a separate system for fantasy contests rather than keep it within the Sports Wagering Act.
  • Removing the special limit on loss recovery could let the general rule apply to fantasy-contest losses, where its requirements are met.

Case against#

  • One concern is that removing the fantasy-contest exception could expose participants to gambling charges without the bill clearly explaining which contests would be affected.
  • The bill removes a dedicated licensing system but does not set out replacement rules for operators or players.
  • Repealing the fantasy-contest and exchange-wager taxes could reduce state revenue, but the bill provides no estimate of how much.