Counties Could Tighten Energy Project Siting

Summary#

HB 5837, titled “LOC GOVT-ENERGY FACILTIES,” would amend the Illinois Counties Code sections on commercial wind and solar facilities and energy storage systems. Its stated goal is not given in the supplied material. The bill is introduced and has not become law.

  • County boards may require setbacks greater than the distances already set out in the Code, after finding that the setback distances would impair residential, commercial, agricultural, or industrial development, or negatively affect property values in those areas.
  • County boards may deny siting approval, a special-use permit, or a change to an approved permit if they find one of five conditions: the facility is next to a water treatment facility; it is in a Metropolitan Statistical Area (an area designated by the U.S. Office of Management and Budget); it would limit housing opportunities; it would damage existing agricultural areas; or a road could not handle its traffic.
  • These denial grounds apply to commercial wind and solar facilities and to energy storage systems covered by the Code. The Code’s definition excludes storage systems associated with commercial wind or solar facilities.
  • The bill gives counties permission to use these powers; it does not require them to impose larger setbacks or deny any permit.

What it means for you#

  • County governments: County boards would have additional discretion over setbacks and permit decisions. The bill does not require a county to use that discretion.
  • Energy project owners and developers: A project could face larger setbacks or be denied for one of the listed reasons. The bill does not set out a new application process or say what evidence a county must use to make these findings.
  • Residents, landowners, and businesses: The bill does not directly change property rights, create compensation, or require a facility to be built or stopped. Its effects would depend on county decisions.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not directly impose a tax or fee.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of these proposed changes is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not identify an appropriation or estimate for county staff or other administrative costs. Any added county costs are unknown.
  • The supplied material does not identify a new tax, fee, fine, or benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text has no visible markup showing which wording is new. The synopsis describes the proposed additions, but the current parent Act was not supplied, so the exact change from current law could not be verified.
  • The bill does not explain what evidence would support a finding that a setback would harm development or property values, or that a facility would limit housing or damage agricultural areas.
  • It is unclear how the new power to deny permits interacts with the Code’s existing rule that a permit request meeting applicable standards and conditions must be approved.
  • The bill does not specify a new review process, decision deadline, appeal route, or reporting requirement for these findings.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that counties would have more ways to respond to local conditions that the listed setback rules may not address.
  • Allowing denial where a county finds a risk to water treatment facilities, housing, agricultural areas, or road capacity could let local officials weigh those concerns before approving a project.
  • Allowing larger setbacks could give counties another tool to address local development or property-value concerns.

Case against#

  • The bill gives county boards broad discretion, but does not specify what evidence or standards they must use for several findings.
  • One listed reason for denial is that a facility would be in a Metropolitan Statistical Area. The bill does not explain how that location-based ground should be weighed against the other criteria.
  • It is unclear whether a county could deny a project that otherwise meets the Code’s standards, given the existing approval rule described above.
  • Larger setbacks could affect where projects can be built, but the bill does not explain how counties should balance that effect against the stated development and property-value finding.