Auditor General to audit teacher program costs

Summary#

HR-1026, “Audit-Grow Your Own Illinois,” is an Illinois House resolution, not a bill that changes the law. If adopted, it would direct the Auditor General to audit the Grow Your Own Illinois program; its stated goal is to check how the program uses taxpayer money and what outcomes it achieves.

  • The audit must cover the program’s management, performance, and finances, including spending since 2018.
  • It must examine spending on staff, buildings and rent, student financial aid, and wrap-around services (support services for students).
  • It must examine how many students were accepted, graduated from their teaching program, or did not graduate successfully.
  • The Illinois Board of Higher Education, State Board of Education, Grow Your Own Illinois, and related agencies or entities must cooperate fully and promptly.
  • The Auditor General must begin as soon as possible and report findings and recommendations when the audit is complete. The resolution does not set a completion date.

The resolution’s preamble says the program’s annual cost per new teacher is over $70,000. That is a claim used to explain the proposed audit, not an audit finding.

What it means for you#

  • Taxpayers and the public: The resolution would call for an audit and a report, but does not itself change taxes, program funding, or public services.
  • Grow Your Own Illinois students: The resolution does not change eligibility, financial aid, or services, and does not require students to take any action.
  • State agencies and program entities: They must cooperate with the audit and provide useful information. The Auditor General would examine the program; the resolution does not set out an application or review process for students.

Money#

No publicly available information on the audit’s cost or a new appropriation is included in the resolution.

  • The audit would require the Auditor General to do work, but the resolution gives no staffing plan or cost estimate.
  • It asks the audit to break down program spending since 2018; it does not authorize or change that spending.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution gives no deadline for finishing the audit, beyond directing it to begin as soon as possible.
  • It does not define “not successfully graduated” or set out how student outcomes should be counted.
  • It does not specify the audit’s methods or the report’s recipients. It refers to the Illinois State Auditing Act, but that Act was not supplied, so its reporting requirements could not be checked.
  • No publicly available information in the supplied material explains whether the audit would examine outcomes such as whether graduates become or remain teachers.

Case for#

  • An audit could give the public a clearer account of program costs and how money is divided among staff, facilities, aid, and student services.
  • Checking acceptance and graduation numbers alongside spending could help assess what the program is producing for its cost.
  • Requiring related agencies and program entities to cooperate could help the Auditor General obtain information from across the organizations involved.

Case against#

  • The audit would take staff time, but the resolution gives no estimate of its cost or staffing needs.
  • The required student measures focus on acceptance and graduation. Those figures alone may not explain why students leave or whether graduates go on to teach.
  • The resolution sets no finish date, so it does not guarantee when the public will receive the findings.