High ethanol fuel tax exemption for farms

Summary#

HF-2798 would add a section to Iowa’s existing fuel-tax law; it would not create a new program. Its stated goal is to exempt certain high-ethanol gasoline from the excise tax when it is bought exclusively for agricultural use. The bill was withdrawn and is not law.

  • The exemption would cover gasoline with more than 85% ethanol by volume, bought at a terminal or refinery rack exclusively for use in an implement of husbandry used in agricultural production.
  • A purchaser would need a complete, correct exemption certificate provided by the Iowa Department of Revenue, signed by the purchaser and kept by the supplier for at least three years.
  • The Department would have to disallow the exemption without proof from a certificate.
  • If a purchaser used or disposed of the fuel in a nonexempt way, the purchaser would owe the excise tax directly to the Department.

What it means for you#

  • Agricultural purchasers: For qualifying fuel, the tax would not be imposed or collected at purchase. The bill’s explanation says that under current law, tax-paid fuel used for an exempt purpose, including in agricultural implements, may instead be claimed as a refund.
  • Purchasers who later use or dispose of the fuel in a nonexempt way: You would be solely liable for the excise tax and have to pay it directly to the Department.
  • Fuel suppliers: You would have to retain the exemption certificates for at least three years.
  • Other fuel buyers: The bill would not exempt gasoline with 85% ethanol or less, or fuel bought for uses outside the stated agricultural purpose.

Money#

No cost or revenue estimate is provided in the supplied material. No publicly available information.

  • The bill would prevent collection of the excise tax on qualifying purchases, which could reduce state tax receipts; the amount is unknown.
  • The bill does not state an appropriation or a staffing amount.
  • Suppliers would have to retain certificates, but the materials do not estimate the cost of doing so.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Iowa law is not supplied, so the current-law description in the bill’s explanation could not be checked against the full law.
  • The bill leaves the certificate’s detailed requirements to the Department’s director.
  • The bill does not give a start date or explain how the exemption would interact with the existing refund process.
  • The bill does not define “implement of husbandry” or explain what counts as using or disposing of fuel in a nonexempt way.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that eligible purchasers would not have to pay the tax first and seek a refund later.
  • Requiring a signed certificate and supplier records could provide proof that the fuel was bought for the exempt use.
  • Making the purchaser responsible for tax after nonexempt use could help limit the exemption to its stated purpose.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill would forgo tax collection on qualifying purchases, but the materials do not estimate the revenue effect.
  • Purchasers and suppliers would have certificate and recordkeeping duties, and the bill does not estimate their costs.
  • The bill leaves important details, including certificate requirements and the meaning of nonexempt use or disposal, unstated.