Hands-free rule for school and construction zones

Summary#

HB 2792 would add a new rule to Kansas’s uniform traffic law and amend the existing traffic-fine schedule in K.S.A. 8-2118. Its stated goal is to prohibit mobile-phone use while driving in certain school and road construction zones; it is introduced and is not law.

  • Drivers could not use a mobile telephone without a hands-free device in a school zone while a reduced speed limit is being enforced, or in a road construction zone while workers are present.
  • The bill provides exceptions for on-duty law enforcement and emergency personnel, vehicles safely and lawfully stopped, and hands-free use. It also allows certain calls, including reporting ongoing illegal activity, seeking emergency help, and dispatch communications for transit or for-hire operators using a permanently affixed device.
  • Holding a phone in a covered zone would create a rebuttable presumption of a violation (a presumption that can be challenged).
  • Police could not take a phone without the person’s consent for compliance checks or as evidence. Downloading phone information would be allowed only with probable cause that the phone was used in a crime, a valid search warrant, or other legal authority.
  • The fine schedule lists the new offense at $60. Officers must issue warning citations until July 1, 2027.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers: In the specified zones, you would need to use a hands-free device or not use your phone, unless an exception applies. The school-zone rule applies only while the reduced speed limit is being enforced; the construction-zone rule applies only while workers are present.
  • Drivers carrying a phone: Holding it in a covered zone could count as evidence of a violation, but it would not automatically establish one.
  • Police: The bill requires warning citations through July 1, 2027, and limits when officers may seize or search a phone.
  • People using phones for navigation or similar tasks: The bill’s definition permits certain functions, such as navigation, in hands-free mode.
  • Current law: The bill amends K.S.A. 8-2118, but the supplied material does not include the unamended law. I could not verify what phone-use restrictions or related rules already apply in Kansas.

Money#

The bill lists a $60 fine, but the available material gives no estimate of public costs or revenue.

  • The $60 amount is in the uniform fine schedule. Warning citations are required until July 1, 2027.
  • Kansas law’s fine schedule says fines for qualifying moving violations in road construction zones are doubled. The supplied material does not establish whether this new offense qualifies, so whether the fine would be $120 in that situation is unclear.
  • No information is provided about enforcement or court costs, staffing, or expected fine revenue.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “workers present,” and the supplied material does not include the laws that define road construction zones or set school-zone speed limits.
  • The supplied text does not show how much of the amended fine schedule is new, beyond the listed mobile-phone offense.
  • It is unclear whether this offense will count as a moving violation for the construction-zone fine increase.
  • The text does not explain how the presumption from holding a phone would be applied in a particular case.
  • The bill would take effect after publication in the statute book if enacted; the supplied material does not give a publication date.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it targets phone use in places where children, road workers, and drivers may be close together.
  • The restrictions are limited to specified zones and conditions, rather than applying everywhere a person drives.
  • Hands-free use and several emergency and work-related uses are allowed.
  • Limits on phone seizure and searches provide privacy protections.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill creates a phone-use offense without explaining how “workers present” will be established or how the presumption from holding a phone will work in practice.
  • Drivers may face a fine after the warning period, and the possible construction-zone fine increase is unclear.
  • Because the supplied material does not show the current law, it is difficult to tell how this rule would overlap with existing restrictions.
  • The bill does not provide details on enforcement, such as how officers should distinguish prohibited use from permitted hands-free use.