Criminalizes interfering with worship, adds civil remedies

Summary#

Kansas Senate Bill 520 would create a new crime and civil lawsuit option, and amend the state’s criminal desecration law and the Attorney General’s authority under existing laws. Its stated goal is to protect people exercising religious freedom at a place of worship and the property of those places. The supplied status lists the bill as introduced; it is not law on that information.

  • A person would commit the new crime by using force, threat of force or physical obstruction to intentionally injure, intimidate or interfere with someone exercising or seeking to exercise religious freedom at a place of worship. Intentionally damaging, defacing or destroying that place’s property would also be a crime.
  • The bill sets different criminal penalties by conduct and, for property damage, by the property’s value. Possessing certain firearms or weapons while committing the person-focused offense would make it aggravated interference, a more serious felony.
  • A person injured by conduct that would meet the new crime’s definition could sue for damages and other relief. The Attorney General could bring such a civil case for a victim or on the Attorney General’s own determination.
  • The bill would add places of worship to the property covered by the criminal desecration law. It would also give the Attorney General concurrent authority to prosecute the new crimes when they are part of alleged criminal conduct in two or more counties.
  • The bill does not set a start date beyond taking effect after publication in the statute book.

What it means for you#

  • People at a place of worship: The new offense would apply only to the specified intentional conduct at a place of worship. “Physical obstruction” means blocking entry or exit, or making passage unreasonably difficult or hazardous. “Intimidate” means causing a reasonable fear of bodily harm to someone.
  • People accused of the offense: The bill classifies the person-focused offense as a severity level 10 person felony, or level 6 for a second or later conviction. If the person is in possession of a firearm or weapon in violation of specified weapons laws, aggravated interference would be a level 4 person felony. Property damage would be a misdemeanor if the damage is under $1,000, and a felony at higher values.
  • People injured by the conduct: A person could seek actual damages, or choose $5,000 for each violation instead. A court could also award punitive damages up to three times actual damages, attorney fees and costs, and equitable or injunctive relief. The bill does not say a criminal conviction is required before bringing the civil case.
  • Places of worship: The bill would add damage to a place of worship to criminal desecration. Its proposed penalties use the same property-value tiers as the new offense, but the bill does not explain how the two offenses would interact.
  • Attorney General and county or district attorneys: The Attorney General could bring the new criminal charges alongside local prosecutors when the alleged course of conduct spans at least two counties. The Attorney General could also bring civil cases under the bill.

Money#

No publicly available information. The supplied material has no cost estimate.

  • The bill authorizes the Attorney General to pursue civil cases and adds concurrent criminal authority, but gives no staffing or funding estimate.
  • A successful civil plaintiff could receive damages and legal costs. In an Attorney General civil case, a court could also impose a civil penalty: $10,000 or $15,000 for a first violation, and $15,000 or $25,000 for a later violation, depending on whether it is classified as nonviolent. The bill does not say who receives that penalty.
  • The bill does not state criminal fine amounts.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current full texts of the laws being amended, so the exact differences from current law cannot be verified.
  • The bill does not define “nonviolent,” “lawfully exercising” religious freedom, or what counts as a “place of religious worship.”
  • It does not explain how the new crime and criminal desecration would interact when the same property damage could fit both definitions.
  • It sets no procedures, reporting rules or review process for the Attorney General’s decision to bring a civil case.
  • The civil filing deadline is five years after the later of discovering the violation or the end of a related criminal case. The bill does not explain how that rule applies if there is no related criminal case.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would make force, threats, obstruction and intentional property damage at places of worship subject to specific criminal penalties.
  • Higher penalties for weapon-related conduct could reflect the added risk described by the bill.
  • The civil option could let an injured person seek compensation or an order to stop conduct, without relying only on criminal penalties.
  • Allowing the Attorney General to act across county lines could help address alleged conduct spanning multiple counties.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define several terms that affect who may be sued or charged, including “nonviolent” and “place of religious worship.”
  • A possible trade-off is that the new criminal offense and civil lawsuit could expose a person to both criminal penalties and substantial civil damages for the same conduct.
  • The bill does not explain how prosecutors should handle overlap with criminal desecration, or how decisions to bring civil cases would be guided.
  • The Attorney General could seek civil penalties in addition to relief for a victim, but the bill does not specify where those penalties go or estimate the cost of administering the expanded authority.