Medical-intervention access protected by bill

Summary#

SB 522 would create a new law, the Kansas Medical Freedom Act; it does not amend a named existing Act. Its stated goal is to prevent people from being denied access to certain services because they use or do not use a medical intervention. The supplied status says a Senate committee recommended passage as amended, so the bill is not yet law; the supplied text does not show the amendments.

  • Private entities could not deny, restrict or penalize access to services, products, venues or transportation based on a person’s use or nonuse of a medical intervention. The bill defines that term broadly, including masks, vaccines, tests and many other treatments or devices.
  • Government and private entities could not require a medical intervention as a condition of employment. Schools and learning gatherings could not require one for participation or entry.
  • Government entities could not require a medical intervention for access to government services, licenses, permits, benefits, public facilities or transportation, or government employment.
  • Ticket issuers could not discriminate against or deny access based on medical-intervention status. A separate exception allows intimate facilities or programs to be maintained based on biological sex, regardless of medical intervention related to gender transition.
  • The Attorney General must investigate every complaint and issue a final order within 60 days. The Attorney General may assess civil penalties of up to $10,000 per violation for an entity with fewer than 100 individuals, or $50,000 for an entity with 100 or more.

What it means for you#

  • People using or declining medical interventions: Private entities could not deny, restrict or penalize your access to the listed services, products, venues or transportation on that basis. The bill does not say this would guarantee access for other reasons.
  • Workers and employers: Government and private employers could not make a medical intervention a condition of employment. Personal protective equipment (PPE) could still be required under workplace safety standards if the requirement follows federal and state safety rules and does not discriminate based on medical-intervention status. The bill separately bars requiring or subjecting someone to PPE for a purpose authorized only under an emergency-use authorization or a similar emergency order.
  • Students and schools: Schools, including day care facilities, K–12 and postsecondary institutions, could not require an intervention for entry or participation. The same rule applies to conferences, symposiums and learning gatherings.
  • Public agencies: They could not require an intervention for the listed government services, benefits, permits, facilities or jobs. These rules would apply during declared emergencies as well.
  • People filing complaints: An aggrieved individual could complain to the Attorney General. If an employer terminated an employee, the Attorney General could not file a civil action against the employer if it reinstated the employee with back pay to the date the complaint was received.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The Attorney General must investigate each complaint and issue a final order within 60 days; the supplied material gives no estimate of the cost or staffing needed.
  • The Attorney General may impose civil penalties of up to $10,000 or $50,000 per violation, depending on the entity’s size. The bill does not say how much might be collected or where the money would go.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include current Kansas law, so it is not possible to verify how much of this bill would change existing rules or overlap with them.
  • The committee recommended passage “as amended,” but the supplied text does not show the amendments. The final proposed wording may differ.
  • The bill does not explain how complaints would be investigated, what evidence or standards would apply, or how a penalty would be set.
  • “Ticket holders” is defined as a person or group providing access to an event, such as a venue or promoter, but the ticket provision uses the term in a way that leaves unclear who is protected from denied entry.
  • The bill does not explain how its workplace PPE exception interacts with its rule against PPE required for a purpose authorized only under an emergency-use authorization or similar emergency declaration.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to protect access to everyday services, work, education and government services regardless of whether someone uses a medical intervention.
  • Applying the rules during emergencies would prevent those protections from being suspended during a public health crisis.
  • A complaint process with a required decision within 60 days could give a person a defined route to challenge an alleged violation.
  • The workplace safety exception preserves PPE requirements that meet federal and state safety rules and do not discriminate based on medical-intervention status.

Case against#

  • The definition of “medical intervention” covers many kinds of procedures, products and devices. One concern is that the bill could restrict entities’ choices across a wide range of services and settings.
  • The bill applies during emergencies and limits some emergency-related PPE requirements. A possible trade-off is less room for government or private entities to respond to an emergency.
  • The bill requires the Attorney General to investigate every complaint within a 60-day process, but does not specify procedures or provide a cost estimate.
  • The ticket-holder wording and the relationship between the PPE provisions leave important questions about the bill’s reach unresolved.