Investigations of school staff misconduct expanded

Summary#

“An Act Regarding School Employee Investigations” amends Maine’s existing education law, including the investigation rules in Title 20-A. It requires investigations and reporting for certain alleged misconduct involving school employees; its stated goal is to examine current procedures and recommend improvements. The law was enacted as an emergency and took effect when approved on April 15, 2026.

  • A superintendent must investigate a complaint involving conduct covered by the law and notify the Department of Education (DOE) when the investigation starts. Covered conduct includes alcohol or illegal drugs, abuse, specified inappropriate contact, harassment, sexual assault, stalking, sexual exploitation of a minor, and similar conduct that endangers a student or another employee.
  • The school entity must immediately put an employee under a covered investigation on paid leave, finish the investigation even if the employee leaves, and report its findings and outcome to the DOE.
  • The DOE must keep a notation of a pending investigation in the employee’s department records, visible to superintendents and other authorized school administrators. It must update or remove the notation based on the outcome and appeals.
  • Before offering a job, a school entity must check relevant DOE records for the applicant’s certification or eligibility and any investigation notation.
  • The DOE must convene a working group and report findings and recommendations to the Legislature by January 15, 2027.

What it means for you#

  • School employees: An employee who is the subject of a covered investigation must be placed on paid leave immediately. The investigation continues if the employee resigns or is dismissed. If the school entity finds misconduct by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not), it must report the information to the DOE and to any school entity that requests it, even if a confidentiality agreement says otherwise. The employee may submit a written rebuttal to a final report sent to the DOE.
  • Schools and school administrators: They must investigate covered complaints, notify the DOE, report outcomes, and check department records before offering employment. These duties apply to the school entities named in the law, including public and approved private schools.
  • Other school employers: The DOE must notify other school entities where the employee works about certain discipline or the employee leaving before an investigation is complete. For a prospective employer, notice that a credential holder left during an investigation requires that person’s consent as part of the job application.
  • The public: The law does not make investigation records generally public. It allows specified sharing with school entities, which must keep confidential information confidential.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • School entities must pay employees placed on leave and carry out investigations. The bill gives no estimate of these costs.
  • The DOE must convene a working group, maintain investigation notations and records, and prepare a report. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The commissioner must appoint a certification hearing officer for covered investigations. The text does not specify that officer’s duties or the cost of the appointment.

What is unclear#

  • The prior version of the amended law was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which investigation and reporting duties are new and which were already in force.
  • The law does not set out investigation steps, deadlines for school entities to finish investigations, or a process for challenging a pending notation.
  • “Similar” conduct that endangers health, safety or welfare is not defined. The law also does not explain how to handle cases where the allegation is not confirmed but appeal rights have not ended.
  • The law directs the commissioner to appoint a certification hearing officer but does not state the officer’s role.
  • The working group must make recommendations, but the law does not require the Legislature to adopt them.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that requiring investigations to continue after an employee leaves may help prevent a departure from leaving serious allegations unresolved.
  • Required record checks and notices could give school employers information about pending or completed investigations when making hiring decisions.
  • The working group must examine how the procedures are being used across different types of schools and recommend improvements, including on reporting and training.

Case against#

  • One concern is that paid leave is mandatory as soon as an employee becomes the subject of a covered investigation, with no exception or time limit stated in the bill.
  • A pending-investigation notation is visible to authorized school administrators before a finding is made. The bill does not specify how quickly investigations must be completed.
  • The rule requiring disclosure of substantiated findings to any school entity that requests them may limit the effect of confidentiality agreements, even though the law requires receiving entities to keep confidential information confidential.
  • The bill assigns new investigation, recordkeeping and reporting work but provides no cost estimate or detailed process for carrying it out.