One-year expulsion for sexual assault

Summary#

The supplied title describes a resolve directing the Department of Education to develop guidance on supportive measures for young students. But the bill text is an act about expelling students for sexual assault; it does not direct the department to develop guidance. The text would amend Maine’s education law, Title 20-A, section 1001. The bill is listed as failed, so it did not become law.

  • School boards would have to adopt a policy for expelling students in any grade who are found to have committed sexual assault on school grounds or other school property, and referring the matter to local law enforcement.
  • The student would have to be expelled for at least one year, unless the school board authorizes the superintendent to change that requirement in writing, case by case.
  • A principal could immediately suspend a student for good cause, subject to investigation and due-process requirements.
  • The bill would make this expulsion rule an exception to restrictions on out-of-school suspensions and expulsions for students in grade 5 or below.
  • Schools could provide educational services in an alternative setting to an expelled student, but would not have to do so under this bill.

What it means for you#

  • Students and families: If a student were found to have committed sexual assault on school grounds or other school property, the proposed policy would require expulsion for at least one year, unless the superintendent changed that requirement in writing under the board’s case-by-case authority. The bill does not set out a separate process for making that decision.
  • Students with disabilities: A placement change would have to follow the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.
  • School boards and school leaders: Boards would have to adopt an expulsion-and-referral policy. Principals could use immediate suspension only with good cause and in line with investigation and due-process requirements.
  • Local law enforcement: The school-board policy would have to provide for referral to the appropriate local law enforcement agency.
  • Young students: The bill would create an exception to the stated limits on out-of-school suspension and expulsion for students in grade 5 or below. The text does not set a separate minimum age or grade for the proposed sexual-assault rule.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of the proposal.

  • The bill text gives no spending amount, staffing estimate, or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied title and bill text conflict. The text does not include the promised Department of Education guidance on supportive measures.
  • The current version of the amended law was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which rules the bill would change in practice.
  • The bill does not define how a student would be “determined” to have committed sexual assault, beyond referring to investigation and due process provisions elsewhere in the law.
  • It does not set criteria for the superintendent’s written, case-by-case decision to change the one-year expulsion requirement.
  • The bill does not specify how a school would provide educational services in an alternative setting, or require those services.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that sexual assault on school property calls for a clear, serious school response and referral to local law enforcement.
  • A minimum one-year expulsion could make the stated consequence more consistent across school boards, while retaining a written, case-by-case exception.
  • The bill’s reference to due process and federal disability law recognizes that school action must follow those protections.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill sets a one-year minimum expulsion but does not explain how the finding is made or what evidence standard applies.
  • The exception depends on a superintendent’s written decision, but the bill gives no criteria for that decision.
  • The bill permits alternative educational services but does not require them, so access to education after expulsion is not assured by this text.
  • The proposal concerns expulsion and referrals, not the supportive measures described in its supplied title.