Consent required for indigent defense payments

Summary#

LD 2195 amends Maine’s law on indigent legal services, including section 1802-A of the Maine Revised Statutes. Its title states a goal of preventing attorney appointments or assignments without consent; the new wording instead limits when the Commission is required to pay or reimburse an attorney. The bill was signed into law on April 3, 2026.

  • The Commission is not required to pay or reimburse a court-appointed or assigned attorney unless all three conditions are met: the attorney is “assigned counsel,” the Commission has found the attorney eligible for that type of proceeding, and the attorney agreed in advance.
  • The bill does not expressly prohibit a court from appointing or assigning an attorney who has not consented.
  • It also does not expressly say the Commission must pay or reimburse an attorney once all three conditions are met.
  • It changes the section’s heading, but the available material does not show the full existing law or how much of the compensation rule is new.

What it means for you#

  • Attorneys: Advance consent is one condition for the Commission to be required to pay or reimburse you for a court appointment or assignment. You must also be “assigned counsel” and have the Commission’s eligibility determination for that type of proceeding.
  • Courts and the Commission: The bill does not set out a process for checking consent or eligibility, and it does not expressly bar appointments made without consent.
  • People who use indigent legal services: The bill does not directly change eligibility for legal services or set out a new service or appointment process.

Money#

No cost estimate or other financial information is provided in the available material.

  • The bill changes when the Commission is required to reimburse expenses or compensate an attorney, but gives no estimate of the effect on spending.
  • It does not specify an appropriation, staffing change, fee, or fine.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “assigned counsel” in the supplied text.
  • It does not explain how the Commission decides eligibility for each type of proceeding, or how attorneys can challenge a decision.
  • It does not say what happens if a court appoints or assigns an attorney without advance consent.
  • The supplied material does not include the prior text of section 1802-A, so the full difference from existing law cannot be verified.
  • The material does not state when the new provision takes effect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that attorneys should not be required to take indigent-service appointments without agreeing in advance.
  • Requiring an eligibility determination for the type of proceeding may help ensure appointments match the Commission’s assessment of an attorney’s eligibility.
  • Setting these conditions for required payment could make the limits on Commission compensation clearer.

Case against#

  • The bill’s title suggests a ban on appointments without consent, but its operative wording does not expressly prohibit a court from making one.
  • The text does not clearly guarantee payment even when the attorney consents and meets the other conditions.
  • One concern is that an attorney could be appointed without consent and the Commission would not be required to compensate or reimburse them.
  • The bill does not explain how courts, attorneys, and the Commission would coordinate consent and eligibility decisions.