Nonlawyers may represent the state in appeals

Summary#

LD 2180, An Act to Make Changes to the Laws Regarding the Department of Administrative and Financial Services, Bureau of Human Resources and the State Civil Service Appeals Board, is now law. It amends Maine laws on who may represent the State in certain proceedings and on how state employee grievances move through the appeals process. Its stated goal is to make changes to laws governing those offices and processes.

  • It permits a nonlawyer to represent the State before the State Civil Service Appeals Board in certain reclassification, reallocation or reorganization appeals, and before an arbitrator in a grievance under a collective bargaining agreement.
  • It revises deadlines and steps for state employees’ grievances, including when an employee must submit a grievance to a department or agency head and when that head must meet with the employee and issue a written decision.
  • For certain disciplinary decisions made after a due-process meeting, the department or agency head’s written decision is treated as the final decision at the agency level. A classified employee may appeal to the State Human Resources Officer; an unclassified employee may appeal directly to the board.
  • It changes deadlines for appeals to the State Human Resources Officer and the board. The board’s decision remains binding on the parties.

What it means for you#

  • State employees: The bill sets a revised sequence and deadlines for pursuing a grievance. For example, an employee must submit a grievance in writing to the department or agency head within 21 days of becoming aware of it. The department or agency head must meet with the employee within 20 working days after receiving the notice and issue a written decision within five working days after the meeting.
  • Classified employees: If dissatisfied with the department or agency head’s written decision, an employee may appeal to the State Human Resources Officer within 21 days of receiving it. The officer must reply in writing within 21 days.
  • Unclassified employees: In the specified case of a written decision after a due-process meeting about proposed discipline, the employee may appeal directly to the board, without another step at the department or agency level.
  • State departments and agencies: They must meet and issue decisions within the stated deadlines. They may designate a representative of at least deputy or assistant department-head, or labor-specialist, level for specified steps.
  • State employees’ representatives: A representative may have access to the employee’s work location at least one day before the grievance is submitted to the department or agency head, to investigate it.
  • General public: The bill does not create a new agency or change taxes, fees, or benefits in the supplied text.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill assigns steps and deadlines to existing state officials and the appeals board, but gives no cost or staffing estimate.
  • For a subpoena, the party requesting it must advance the witness fees and travel allowance; the text does not say this is a new cost.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the full prior law, so it does not allow a complete comparison of which grievance steps and deadlines are new versus already in force.
  • The bill text gives some deadlines in “days” and others in “working days.” It does not explain how “days” are counted.
  • The supplied text does not give an effective date. No publicly available information.
  • It does not explain how the revised steps interact with grievance procedures in particular collective bargaining agreements.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it sets defined deadlines for department-level meetings and written decisions, giving employees and agencies a clearer timetable.
  • Treating certain disciplinary decisions after a due-process meeting as final at the agency level may avoid repeating a department-level step before an appeal.
  • Allowing nonlawyers to represent the State in the listed proceedings may give the State another way to provide representation in those specific cases.

Case against#

  • One concern is that employees and agencies must navigate several deadlines and different appeal routes; missing a deadline can affect the grievance.
  • The bill gives the State permission to use nonlawyer representatives in specified proceedings, but the supplied text does not set out qualifications for those representatives.
  • It is unclear whether the revised deadlines and procedures will require additional staff time or create delays elsewhere in the process.