Criminal Trespassers Act shields occupiers from claims

Summary#

The bill creates The Criminal Trespassers Act and amends The Occupiers’ Liability Act and The Limitations Act. Its stated goal is to change the rules for civil injury or death claims by people who enter premises without permission.

  • For a person aged 12 or older, an occupier generally cannot be sued for an injury or death on the premises if the person entered without permission and intended to commit a criminal act, or the occupier reasonably believed they did.
  • That bar does not apply if the occupier’s conduct was wilful and grossly disproportionate in the circumstances and resulted in a conviction for an indictable Criminal Code offence.
  • The bill broadens an existing limited-duty rule in the Occupiers’ Liability Act to cover any person aged 12 or older who enters without the occupier’s consent or permission. The exact duty that remains is not clear from the supplied text.
  • For claims covered by the new Act, the limitation period (the deadline for starting a lawsuit) does not run from the relevant act or omission until the occupier is convicted and all appeals from the conviction are exhausted.
  • The bill’s schedules say they come into force on royal assent. The supplied text gives no assent date.

What it means for you#

  • Occupiers of premises: If the new Act’s conditions apply, you generally would not face a civil claim for the trespasser’s injury or death. The exception requires both the specified conduct and an indictable Criminal Code conviction. There may be more than one occupier of a premises.
  • People aged 12 or older entering without permission: The new Act applies if you intended to commit a criminal act, or the occupier reasonably believed you did. The amended Occupiers’ Liability Act also changes the duty owed to any person aged 12 or older who enters without permission, even if the new Act’s criminal-intent condition is not met.
  • People making a claim: For claims under the new Act, the limitation clock is paused until conviction and the end of appeals. The bill does not set out a separate process for making or deciding a claim.
  • Children under 12: The new Act’s bar applies only to people aged 12 or older. The supplied text does not show how the amended Occupiers’ Liability Act applies to children under 12.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill sets no fees, fines, benefits, or spending amounts.
  • Any costs to occupiers, claimants, courts, or government are not estimated in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the Occupiers’ Liability Act was not supplied, so the exact duty that remains for an unpermitted entrant, and how much of the amended wording is new, could not be checked.
  • The bill does not define “criminal act,” “wilful,” or “grossly disproportionate.”
  • It is unclear what happens to the limitation period if the occupier is never convicted. The bill says the pause ends when there is a conviction and all appeals are exhausted.
  • The bill gives no process for deciding whether an occupier reasonably believed the person intended a criminal act.
  • The supplied bill text has no royal-assent date, so its actual start date is not available.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to limit civil liability when someone aged 12 or older enters premises without permission with a criminal purpose.
  • A possible argument for the rule is that occupiers should generally not face injury or death claims in those circumstances.
  • The exception preserves a route to a claim when the occupier’s conduct meets a high standard and results in an indictable Criminal Code conviction.
  • Pausing the limitation period during criminal proceedings could prevent the civil deadline from running before those proceedings and appeals are finished.

Case against#

  • The new Act can bar a claim based on the occupier’s reasonable belief about the person’s purpose, even if that purpose is not established as fact.
  • The bill does not explain how that belief or the terms “wilful” and “grossly disproportionate” would be assessed.
  • The exception requires an indictable Criminal Code conviction as well as the specified conduct, so a person may be unable to bring a claim if there is no such conviction.
  • The limitation rule’s effect when no conviction occurs is unclear.
  • Because the supplied text does not include the full existing duty-of-care provision, readers cannot tell precisely what protection remains for other unpermitted entrants.