Summary#
The Advocate for Children and Youth Amendment Act amends Manitoba’s Advocate for Children and Youth Act; it does not create a new office. Its stated goal is to recognize guidance for designing and delivering services for children and youth, and to let the Advocate use agreements and advocate for principles of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. The bill text says it would come into force on royal assent, but the supplied material does not confirm whether it has received assent.
- The preamble would recognize that children and youth of all gender identities, including two-spirit, transgender and non-binary youth, deserve services that respect their dignity. It would also name three international instruments as possible guidance for services.
- The Advocate may make agreements with provincial government departments, branches or offices, and with entities that provide a designated service. The purpose must be to help carry out two existing responsibilities under the Act.
- The Advocate may advocate for the principles of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child while carrying out the Act’s responsibilities.
- A committee of the Assembly must begin a comprehensive review within seven years after the review requirement comes into force, and then once every seven years. It must report within one year after starting, including any amendments it recommends.
What it means for you#
- Children and youth: The preamble would recognize children and youth of all gender identities and name international principles as guidance. The bill does not itself guarantee a particular service or create a new individual right to one.
- The Advocate and provincial government offices or service providers: The Advocate could make agreements with the named departments, branches, offices or entities to help carry out the Advocate’s existing responsibilities. The bill does not require any agreement to be made.
- The Assembly: A committee must review the Act on the stated schedule and report to the Assembly. The bill does not specify which committee would do this.
- The general public: The bill does not create a new agency, change eligibility for services, or set a new application or complaint process.
Money#
No cost estimate is in the supplied material. No publicly available information.
- The bill authorizes agreements but does not set out spending, staffing levels, or a funding amount.
- The required committee reviews may require resources, but the bill gives no cost estimate.
What is unclear#
- The parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify what responsibilities are in the two cited clauses, how “designated service” is defined, or how this bill changes existing practice.
- The bill does not set terms for agreements, such as duration, oversight, or how information would be shared.
- It does not explain how children, youth, Indigenous communities, or service providers would be involved in the reviews or in using the named international instruments as guidance.
- The bill text leaves the royal-assent date blank, and the supplied material does not confirm whether it has become law.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that recognizing children and youth of all gender identities in the Act’s preamble makes the dignity principle explicit.
- Naming the UN conventions and declaration could give guidance to people designing or delivering services, while not dictating specific services in this bill.
- Agreements could help the Advocate carry out existing responsibilities with government offices and entities that provide designated services.
- Regular reviews could give the Assembly a formal chance to consider changes to the Act.
Case against#
- The bill does not explain what agreements may contain or what safeguards would apply. That leaves important details about how the new power would work unclear.
- The preamble names principles and the Advocate may advocate for them, but the bill does not set service standards or explain how anyone could enforce those principles.
- A review could take nearly eight years to begin, and the bill does not provide a faster review process if concerns arise.
- The bill does not state what staff or funding would be available for agreements or recurring reviews.