Summary#
The bill would create a new Manitoba law, the Intimate Partner Violence Death Review Committee Act. It would establish a committee to review selected intimate partner violence deaths; preventing deaths in similar circumstances is the Act’s stated goal, not a guaranteed result.
- The minister would appoint 6 to 12 committee members, including specified representatives from victim services, police, prosecution, a Manitoba university, a victim-services organization and the medical examiner’s office.
- The committee’s duties would be to review selected deaths, monitor trends, patterns and risk factors, and make recommendations. The chair may select a death after consulting the other members.
- The committee could require public bodies and health-information trustees to provide relevant records, including personal and health information. Requests must be limited to the minimum information needed; legally privileged records are excluded.
- Reviews must be private and cannot begin until related criminal proceedings and any inquiry, investigation or inquest under The Fatality Inquiries Act have ended.
- After each review, the committee must report to the minister. Reports must not identify people, and the minister must table each report in the Assembly within the first 15 sitting days after receiving it.
What it means for you#
- People affected by a death: The committee may review a death, but the bill does not require it to review every case. “Intimate partner violence death” includes a homicide by a current or former intimate partner, related homicides of a child, family member or third party, and the perpetrator’s subsequent suicide.
- Public bodies and health-information trustees: They may be required to disclose relevant records for a review or potential review, subject to the limits on necessary information and legal privilege.
- Committee members: They must keep information confidential and protect it from unauthorized access, use or disclosure. They generally cannot be required to testify about information learned through a review.
- General public: Reports would be made public through tabling in the Assembly, but must not identify people. The bill does not require the government to adopt the committee’s recommendations or create a new front-line service for victims.
- The department: It must provide the committee with the technical and administrative support needed to do its work.
Money#
The bill requires the department to provide staff support and expertise, but no cost estimate is available.
- The committee may hire people with specialized knowledge, training or experience. The bill does not specify a budget or say who would pay for this.
- No fees, fines, benefits, or other spending amounts are set out in the bill.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set criteria for choosing deaths, a timeline for completing reviews, or a process for families or others to request a review.
- It does not specify how the committee must make decisions, or require the minister or government to respond to recommendations.
- The bill gives members the powers of commissioners under Part V of The Manitoba Evidence Act. That Act is not supplied, so the exact scope of those powers cannot be verified here.
- The supplied text does not establish whether the bill has received royal assent. It says the Act would come into force 90 days after royal assent.
- The bill uses definitions from other Manitoba laws for some terms; those laws were not supplied, so those definitions could not be checked here.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that reviews of selected deaths could help identify repeated risks and systemic issues, rather than examining each death only in isolation.
- Requiring relevant records, including health information where necessary, could give the committee a broader basis for its recommendations.
- Private reviews, confidentiality rules and reports without identifying information could help protect people’s privacy while allowing findings to be shared publicly.
Case against#
- The chair decides which deaths to select, and the bill gives no selection criteria. Some cases may therefore go unreviewed without a clear explanation of how choices are made.
- The committee can recommend changes, but the bill does not require the government to act on them or explain publicly if it does not.
- The bill permits access to sensitive personal and health information for reviews or potential reviews. Although it limits requests to what is necessary and protects privileged information, it does not set out detailed review procedures in the Act.
- Staffing, administration and possible expert costs are required or permitted, but no funding amount or estimate is provided.