Charter review referrals would go to court

Summary#

The Constitutional Questions Amendment Act would amend Manitoba’s Constitutional Questions Act. Its stated goal is to increase transparency and scrutiny when Manitoba uses the Charter’s notwithstanding clause; it does not require the Legislature to use or stop using that clause.

  • If an Act of the Legislature contains a declaration under section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the Lieutenant Governor in Council must refer that Act to the Manitoba Court of Appeal within 90 days after enactment.
  • The referral must ask whether the provision violates Charter section 2 or sections 7 to 15 and, if it does, whether the violation is reasonable and demonstrably justified under section 1.
  • The Court of Appeal must consider the matter. The bill does not set a deadline for the court’s consideration.
  • The bill applies to Acts of Manitoba’s Legislature. It does not require referrals for federal laws.

What it means for you#

  • Manitoba government: The Lieutenant Governor in Council would have a legal duty to make the referral when an Act meets the bill’s condition.
  • Court of Appeal: The court would have to consider the referred matter and provide the requested opinion.
  • General public: The bill would add a court assessment of specified Charter questions. It does not itself change which rights the notwithstanding clause overrides, or require the government to suspend the law while the court considers it.
  • Legislature: The bill does not prevent it from passing an Act with a section 33 declaration.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires a government referral and court consideration, but gives no estimate of the administrative or court costs.
  • It does not set an appropriation, fee or fine, or specify staffing or resources.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current full Constitutional Questions Act, so it is not possible to verify what referral powers or procedures already exist or how much this adds to them.
  • The bill does not say whether the court’s opinion is binding or what the government must do with it.
  • It does not set a deadline for the court to consider the referral, or say whether the law stays in force while that happens.
  • The supplied copy gives no royal assent date, so it does not establish whether the amendment is in force.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to provide an independent court assessment of the Charter issues raised by a provincial use of section 33.
  • Requiring the referral within 90 days could make that assessment part of the public record soon after the law is enacted.
  • The bill’s preamble recognizes the Legislature’s role while also treating judicial analysis as a source of information about the law’s effects on Charter rights.

Case against#

  • The referral happens after enactment. The bill does not require the law to wait for the court’s view or explain what follows from that view.
  • It is unclear how much practical effect the referral will have if the court’s opinion is not binding.
  • The bill creates court and government work but provides no cost estimate or details about the resources needed.