Budget bills require public review

Summary#

The Budget Bill Public Accountability Act would create a new Act; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to ensure that a bill implementing measures announced in the budget is reviewed by a committee where members of the public can make representations.

  • A budget bill must be referred at the committee stage to a standing committee that gives the public an opportunity to make representations.
  • The committee cannot meet until at least seven days after the later of the bill’s introduction and public notice of the meeting’s date, time and place.
  • The committee must meet for at least 10 hours, unless every committee member agrees to a shorter time.
  • The bill sets a review process; it does not itself change taxes, spending measures or other budget policies.

What it means for you#

  • Members of the public: You would have an opportunity to make representations to the committee reviewing a budget bill. The bill does not require you to take part.
  • The Legislative Assembly and its committees: They would have to refer budget bills for this committee review and meet the timing and minimum-duration rules.
  • People affected by budget measures: The bill does not give the public a veto or require the committee to change the bill. The budget bill’s own provisions would determine any direct changes to taxes, services or other policies.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The committee must meet for at least 10 hours unless it unanimously agrees to meet for less. The bill gives no cost estimate for committee or administrative work.
  • The bill states no appropriation, fee, fine or other payment.

What is unclear#

  • The bill defines a “budget bill” as a bill introduced to implement measures announced in the budget, but does not explain how to decide whether a particular bill fits that definition.
  • It does not set out how the public may make representations, how they will be selected or heard, or whether the committee must respond to them.
  • It does not explain how this process would fit with any existing committee procedures. The available material does not describe the current process.
  • The text says the Act comes into force on royal assent, but the supplied text gives no assent date.

Case for#

  • A public committee review would give people a formal opportunity to present views on bills that implement budget measures.
  • The seven-day waiting period could give the public time to learn about the meeting and prepare representations.
  • A minimum of 10 hours could provide more time for review and public input than a brief meeting.

Case against#

  • A mandatory 10-hour minimum could take committee time even when a bill is short or limited in scope; the bill does not provide an exception except by unanimous agreement.
  • The bill requires an opportunity for public representations but does not say how the committee must consider them or whether they can affect the bill.
  • The bill does not define which bills count as budget bills, which could leave uncertainty about when the process is required.