Street Weapons Ban Could Limit Public Carry

Summary#

The Street Weapons Control Act would create a new Manitoba law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to control street weapons in public spaces in populated areas. The Act would start on a date set by proclamation, so it would not take effect automatically on assent.

  • A person must not possess a “street weapon” in a public space in a population centre, subject to exceptions and regulations. Street weapons include long-bladed weapons, axes or hatchets, pepper spray at a specified concentration, and any other items added by regulation.
  • The ban would not apply to certain people and activities, including enforcement officers, some workers acting in their jobs, and transport done as regulations allow. Canada Post and courier employees may carry qualifying pepper spray only if they reasonably require it for protection from animals while working.
  • An enforcement officer who witnesses possession and has reasonable grounds to believe it breaks the Act may seize the weapon, whether or not the person is charged.
  • A seized weapon may have to be returned if the person makes a timely written request, unless a justice orders continued impoundment. It is forfeited to the government if the person consents, is convicted, or misses the request deadline.
  • The Act would apply to a First Nation only if it opts in under regulations. It would not apply where it conflicts with a municipal by-law or First Nation law, to the extent of the conflict.

What it means for you#

  • People in public spaces: If the Act is in force and applies where you are, possessing a covered weapon in a public space in a population centre would be an offence unless an exception or regulation applies. A “public space” includes streets, parks, transit, places open to the public, common areas in multi-unit residences, and unoccupied land.
  • People transporting or storing weapons: Transport is allowed only in accordance with regulations. The Act allows storage in your private residence in a population centre and possession or use on private property you own or occupy.
  • Workers and businesses: Certain manufacturers, sellers, carriers and workers may possess street weapons while acting in the normal course of their duties. A person who reasonably needs a street weapon in the ordinary course of a business, trade or profession is also exempt.
  • People whose weapon is seized: You may have to request its return in writing by a deadline. If you are not charged within 30 days, the request deadline is 60 days after seizure. If you are charged and later acquitted, or the charge is dismissed or stayed, a different 60-day deadline applies. A conviction or missed deadline means you cannot request its return under this Act.
  • First Nations: The Act would apply only after an opt-in under rules to be made by regulation.
  • People generally: A first offence could bring a fine of up to $5,000, up to three months in jail, or both. A second or later offence could bring up to $10,000, up to six months in jail, or both. Hindering or obstructing an enforcement officer is also an offence.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill provides no spending estimate. It may require enforcement officers and other prescribed people to seize, store and return weapons, but the staffing and operating costs are not stated.
  • It sets maximum fines but gives no estimate of fine revenue or enforcement costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not give a start date; that would be set by proclamation.
  • Regulations could add street weapons, places and exemptions, and set transport and return-request rules. Those regulations are not provided.
  • “Long-bladed weapon” depends on a definition in The Long-Bladed Weapon Control Act, which was not supplied. Its exact scope could not be checked. The bill also lets regulations change which weapons count as street weapons.
  • The bill does not explain how a person would challenge a seizure or what happens to a weapon while a return request is being decided.
  • It does not explain how the Act’s First Nation opt-in would work in practice, or how it would interact with First Nation laws where there is no direct conflict.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to limit the carrying of specified weapons in public spaces in populated areas, while allowing stated exceptions for work, transport and other regulated circumstances.
  • Seizure may let enforcement officers act when they witness possession they reasonably believe breaks the Act, without first needing to lay a charge.
  • The bill provides a route to request a weapon’s return and allows a justice to order continued impoundment when it may be needed for an investigation or trial and is in the public interest.
  • First Nations can choose whether the Act applies on their territory.

Case against#

  • The ban covers a wide range of places, including common areas of apartment buildings and unoccupied land. The meaning of some terms and the list of weapons can also be changed by regulation.
  • An officer may seize a weapon without charging the person. A person who misses the return deadline loses the weapon, and the bill does not describe a process to challenge the seizure.
  • A justice may order continued impoundment on an application made without notice to the person whose weapon was seized.
  • The bill allows regulations to set key exceptions and conditions, but those rules are not included here. It is therefore unclear how the ban and exemptions would work in many situations.