Lifetime ban after two impaired-driving convictions

Summary#

The Highway Traffic Amendment Act amends Manitoba’s Highway Traffic Act and makes related changes to The Drivers and Vehicles Act. Its stated goal is to add public-safety measures related to impaired driving. The bill says it takes effect on a day set by proclamation; the supplied material gives no start date.

  • Drivers of class 1, 2, 3 or 4 vehicles must not operate or have care or control of them with any alcohol in their blood.
  • Novice and “restricted” drivers must not have alcohol in their blood or a drug detected by approved screening equipment when driving specified vehicles. Regulations would set which licence classes and vehicles count as “restricted” and, for restricted drivers, which vehicles are covered.
  • A person convicted of an impaired-driving offence would face an alcohol prohibition until they have held a valid licence for two years after their suspension or disqualification ends. Two unrelated convictions within 10 years would mean a lifetime alcohol prohibition.
  • Certain drivers who fail an alcohol screening test or refuse a breath demand, but are not charged criminally for the refusal, would also face a two-year alcohol prohibition, measured by time holding a valid licence.
  • Some roadside licence suspensions would increase from three days to at least seven days, with four more days if a passenger is under 16. The bill also changes when ignition-interlock participation is required.
  • The bill moves a licence-examination rule out of the Highway Traffic Act. Under the amended Drivers and Vehicles Act, the registrar may refuse a licence unless the applicant passes an examination.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers of class 1–4 vehicles: You must have no alcohol in your blood while operating or having care or control of one of these vehicles. A contravention can lead to suspension or disqualification.
  • Novice and restricted drivers: The bill creates alcohol and drug prohibitions for specified vehicles. For drug testing, the rule is based on whether approved equipment detects a drug; the bill does not set a concentration threshold.
  • Supervising drivers: The bill lets regulations set alcohol limits or drug prohibitions for people supervising learners, and can allow licence surrender, suspension or disqualification rules. These requirements depend on regulations; the bill does not itself set all of them.
  • People convicted of impaired driving: The two-year alcohol prohibition starts at conviction and continues until, after the driving suspension or disqualification ends, you have held a valid licence for two years. A second unrelated impaired-driving conviction within 10 years brings a lifetime prohibition. The bill also applies these rules to some earlier offences when a conviction occurs after the new rules take effect.
  • Drivers receiving a three-month suspension: Ignition-interlock participation would be required immediately after the suspension. For a person convicted of impaired driving, the requirement after the post-conviction suspension may be removed if the Licence Suspension Appeal Board allows driving without an interlock on public-safety grounds.
  • Licence applicants: The registrar may refuse to issue a licence unless you pass an examination. The bill does not make passing automatic or set examination details here.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill gives no estimate for government costs, enforcement, staffing or returns.
  • Regulations may provide for vehicle removal and storage when certain drivers’ licences are suspended, and for recovering those costs. The bill does not set amounts.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “novice driver” here. “Restricted driver” status and the vehicles covered depend on regulations.
  • The bill permits many enforcement details to be set by regulation, including testing, licence surrender, suspension, disqualification and vehicle removal. No publicly available information on those future regulations is supplied.
  • The amount of penalties under the referenced penalty section is not in the supplied material.
  • The bill does not give the proclamation date. No publicly available information on that date is supplied.
  • The supplied material does not include the current Acts, so the full existing wording and every change to current law could not be checked. The explanatory note describes some current rules and intended changes.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to reduce impaired driving by setting stricter alcohol rules for certain drivers and creating a drug-detection rule for novice and restricted drivers.
  • Longer roadside suspensions could mean a more serious immediate consequence for the listed incidents.
  • Requiring interlock participation after a three-month suspension would apply before a criminal case is finally decided, rather than waiting for a conviction.
  • A lifetime alcohol prohibition after two unrelated impaired-driving convictions within 10 years is a clear, lasting consequence for repeat convictions.

Case against#

  • Some major details depend on future regulations, so drivers may not know the full rules from this bill alone.
  • The bill allows a lifetime prohibition after two convictions and applies some prohibitions to earlier offences when convictions occur after the new rules start.
  • The registrar’s power to refuse a licence unless an examination is passed is stated to be at the registrar’s “absolute discretion”; the supplied material gives no decision process or review details.
  • The bill does not provide cost estimates, testing procedures in full, or details on how removal and storage costs would be set or recovered.