Pilot to test unregulated operating rooms

Summary#

HB 1597, Health – Unregulated Space in Hospital Operating Suites – Pilot Project, would add a new section to Maryland’s Health–General Article and create a three-year pilot. Its stated goal is to establish a pilot for unregulated operating-room space inside participating hospitals. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • The Health Services Cost Review Commission would run the pilot and could allow up to five hospitals to take part.
  • A participating hospital may be subject to an alternate rate method, including an exemption from rates that would allow unregulated operating-room space inside a regulated facility.
  • A participating hospital may make that space available to all patients and payers, without duplicating services in the hospital’s regulated operating-room space.
  • The Commission must develop criteria and standards. These must include charity care consistent with regulated hospital services, a cap on billed charges compared with a similar service at the hospital, and lower costs to Maryland’s Medical Assistance Program and Medicare than for a similar regulated service.
  • Hospitals must increase consumer awareness about regulated and nonregulated services, including the possibility of additional physician charges. The Commission must report each year, and the pilot would end after June 30, 2029.

What it means for you#

  • Patients: A participating hospital may offer procedures in unregulated operating-room space. The bill does not require a hospital to participate or make the space available. It requires consumer education about possible additional physician charges.
  • Hospitals: The Commission could allow up to five hospitals to participate. Those hospitals would have to meet the Commission’s criteria and standards, including the stated charity-care and charge requirements.
  • Ambulatory and freestanding surgical centers: Each ambulatory surgical center associated with a participating hospital, and each freestanding surgical center in that hospital’s area, must give the Commission information it decides is needed for its annual report.
  • The Commission: It must administer the pilot, set criteria and standards, and report on procedure types and whether outcomes indicate the procedures were appropriate for the unregulated space, participation costs, and effects on Maryland’s AHEAD model.
  • The bill adds a new section, but the current law text was not supplied. What current rules already allow cannot be verified from the available material. No publicly available information.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The Commission must administer the pilot and report each year, but the bill gives no staffing or funding amount.
  • Surgical centers must provide information the Commission determines is needed; the bill does not estimate their costs.
  • The required criteria must include lower costs to Medical Assistance and Medicare than for similar regulated services. The bill does not explain how those costs will be measured or ensure savings in practice.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “unregulated” space or explain what rate rules would apply beyond the possible alternate method or exemption.
  • It does not set out how hospitals apply, how the Commission chooses participants, or when it must make those decisions.
  • It does not specify the procedures that may be performed, or explain how the Commission will decide whether a procedure was appropriate for this space.
  • It does not explain how the billed-charge cap or lower-cost requirement will be calculated or enforced.
  • It does not specify what consumer education must include, beyond the topics named in the bill.

Case for#

  • The pilot could let a small number of hospitals try a different rate approach while keeping the operating-room space physically inside a regulated facility.
  • The bill requires the Commission to set criteria that include charity care and limits on billed charges.
  • Annual reporting could provide information about procedure types, outcomes, costs, and effects on the AHEAD model.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves important operating details to the Commission, including how hospitals are selected and how compliance with the criteria will be checked.
  • The lower-cost requirement does not itself show how savings would be measured or guarantee lower costs in practice.
  • Patients may face additional physician charges; the bill requires hospitals to raise awareness of that possibility but does not set a limit on those charges.