Public funds cover wrongful-conviction awards

Summary#

HB 1605, “Compensation for Individuals Erroneously Convicted – County Cost-Sharing – Repeal,” would amend Maryland’s State Finance and Procurement Article; it would not create a new law. Its stated goal is to repeal counties’ required contribution toward compensation for people wrongfully convicted under state law.

  • The Board of Public Works would still pay eligible people under the existing compensation formula. The bill removes the requirement that the county where the conviction occurred pay the State 50% of the award.
  • It would also remove the related county-payment deadlines, award notices to counties and the Comptroller, and the power to withhold local income tax distributions from a county that does not pay.
  • The bill does not change the existing compensation formula or the possible benefits an administrative law judge may direct an agency or service provider to provide.
  • If enacted, it would take effect October 1, 2026. It is introduced and has not become law; whether it will pass is uncertain.

What it means for you#

  • People eligible for compensation: The bill would not change who qualifies, how the monetary award is calculated, or the possible additional benefits listed in the existing law.
  • County governments: A county would no longer have to repay the State for half of an award when the conviction occurred there. The related payment and notice requirements, and the possible withholding of local income tax distributions for nonpayment, would end.
  • State taxpayers: The State would no longer collect the required county share. In effect, the State would bear the portion counties currently must repay.
  • General public: This bill does not create a new application process or front-line service. It changes who pays part of existing compensation costs.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s fiscal effect or a cost estimate.

  • Under the current wording shown in the bill, counties must pay the State 50% of compensation awards. HB 1605 would remove that requirement, leaving the State to bear that share.
  • The bill does not change the award formula, which is based on the number of days wrongfully confined and the State’s most recent annual median household income.
  • The bill does not change the existing provisions allowing an administrative law judge to direct certain benefits, including housing, health care, education and training, or reimbursement of certain fines, fees, and restitution.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not estimate how much the State would pay instead of counties.
  • It does not say how the repeal would apply to county shares for awards made before the October 1, 2026 effective date.
  • It does not give information about how many awards or what total county payments may be affected.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it removes a county payment obligation tied to a compensation system that the State administers.
  • The State would continue to be responsible for paying eligible people; counties would no longer have to repay half of those awards.
  • Removing the payment notices and withholding process would also end the related administrative requirements for counties and the Comptroller.

Case against#

  • The State would lose the required county contributions and bear those costs instead. The bill gives no estimate of the resulting cost to the State.
  • One concern is that ending county cost-sharing removes a local financial consequence tied to where the conviction occurred. The bill does not explain why that change is preferred.
  • It is unclear how the repeal would handle county shares associated with awards made before the effective date.