Detention facilities face new minimum standards

Summary#

SB 985, “Correctional Services – Immigration Detention Facilities – Minimum Mandatory Standards,” would amend Maryland’s existing Correctional Services law. Its stated goal is to improve standards and compliance to protect health, safety, and welfare. The bill is introduced, and the supplied status says its hearing was canceled; it is not law.

  • The Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services would have to adopt minimum standards for state and local correctional facilities and immigration detention facilities in Maryland, with advice from the Maryland Commission on Correctional Standards. The listed subjects include safety, food, housing and sanitation, individual rights and hearings, and record keeping.
  • The Commission’s reporting, inspection, compliance-plan, audit, and enforcement provisions would cover immigration detention facilities as well as correctional facilities. The Commission could also set up an advisory board on immigration detention facilities.
  • Anyone could report a standards violation, including anonymously through a website link. Licensed health care practitioners and certified security guards would have to report violations they have reason to believe occurred and known breaches of a facility’s computer-system security.
  • Facilities would have to certify each year that specified utilities, heating and cooling, emergency power, and emergency plans are in place. A material change in operations or a material increase in occupancy would require an updated certification within 30 days.
  • The Commission could order a facility to stop operating in specified circumstances, including life-threatening or health-endangering conditions. The Attorney General could sue a private entity for listed violations and seek a civil penalty of up to $10,000 per violation.
  • If a facility is closed, the state, local governing body, or federal entity responsible for its cost would have to pay to transfer and maintain the people detained there.

What it means for you#

  • People held in immigration detention facilities: The bill would bring these facilities under Maryland’s minimum-standards oversight and enforcement system. It does not itself change immigration law or create a right to release.
  • Facility owners, operators, and managers: They would face standards, inspections, reporting and certification requirements, and possible orders to stop operating. They could not impede an inspection. A private entity could face a lawsuit and civil penalties for the violations listed in the bill.
  • Health care practitioners and security guards working at facilities: They would have a duty to report certain standards violations and known computer-system security breaches to the Commission. Their regulating body would have to take disciplinary action if it determines they failed to report.
  • Employees of facilities: A facility could not retaliate against an employee for making a good-faith report of a violation.
  • Taxpayers and responsible governments: They may have costs for oversight or for transferring and maintaining detainees after a closure. The bill assigns transfer costs to the state, local governing body, or federal entity responsible for the closed facility’s cost.
  • People held in correctional facilities: The bill also changes oversight provisions covering correctional facilities, including annual reports on compliance issues. The supplied material does not establish how much of those provisions is new for correctional facilities.

Money#

No total cost estimate is included in the supplied material; no publicly available information on the total public cost is provided.

  • The Commission must employ staff as provided in the state budget. Its technical assistance is limited to what the state budget authorizes.
  • A facility being audited must reimburse the Commission for the cost of outside expertise if the Commission needs that help.
  • A private entity sued under the bill could be ordered to pay a civil penalty of up to $10,000 per violation, plus reasonable legal fees and costs. Penalties would go to the state General Fund.
  • The bill assigns costs of transferring and maintaining detainees after a closure to the state, local governing body, or federal entity responsible for the closed facility’s cost. It does not estimate those costs.

What is unclear#

  • The full current Correctional Services Act was not supplied, so the exact difference from current law—including which correctional-facility duties already exist—could not be fully verified.
  • The bill sets subjects for standards but leaves their detailed requirements to regulations. It does not specify how the Commission will decide whether a facility meets them.
  • Terms such as “material increase” in occupancy and “timely” review are not defined in the bill.
  • The bill does not explain how Maryland’s standards and enforcement would interact with federal oversight of immigration detention facilities.
  • The bill calls for first annual certifications by July 1, 2026, and emergency regulations by June 1, 2026. It is not law according to the supplied status, and the material does not explain how those dates would be handled if it were enacted later.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make minimum standards and oversight apply to immigration detention facilities in Maryland, not only to state and local correctional facilities.
  • Required reports, inspections, certifications, and follow-up after violations could help the Commission identify risks and require corrections.
  • Anonymous public reports and duties for health care practitioners and security guards could provide additional ways to alert the Commission to problems.
  • The bill allows urgent action when a facility poses a serious threat to health or life.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the Commission important enforcement powers, including orders to stop operations, while leaving many standards and procedures to later regulations.
  • The bill does not set out detailed rules for reports, investigations, or decisions on compliance, which could leave key practices unclear.
  • Closure can require governments to pay for transfers and continued detention, but the bill gives no cost estimate or detailed method for deciding which entity is responsible.
  • The bill requires annual certifications and oversight but provides no estimate of the staffing or other resources needed to carry them out.