Civil actions for online child exploitation

Summary#

SB-989, the “Safe Kids Act,” would add a civil-action subtitle to Maryland’s Courts and Judicial Proceedings Article and amend the Criminal Law Article’s child-pornography law. Its stated goals include allowing civil actions over unlawful child exploitation material, authorizing Attorney General enforcement, and extending criminal provisions to AI-generated images and a broader age group. The bill is at first reading, so it is not law; if enacted, it would take effect October 1, 2026.

  • An online platform could not knowingly and intentionally distribute or create/develop unlawful child exploitation material. The bill defines that material to include child pornography, obscene material involving a minor, and certain anatomically accurate devices or images intended for sexual acts.
  • A minor’s parent or legal guardian could sue a platform for a violation. Available relief could include damages, court costs, and attorney and litigation fees; the Attorney General may seek an injunction or other equitable relief.
  • The criminal law would cover images indistinguishable from an actual, identifiable “minor,” replacing “child under the age of 16.” It also expressly includes images created using AI software. The bill does not define “minor.”
  • The bill displays criminal penalties of up to five years in prison and a $2,500 fine, or both; for a person previously convicted under the section, up to 10 years and a $10,000 fine, or both. The text does not show these penalty amounts as changes.
  • Certain service providers, search engines, and cloud providers are outside the civil subtitle to the extent they only transmit, route, store, or connect communications initiated by someone else and are not responsible for creating or developing the material.

What it means for you#

  • Online platforms: The ban applies only to knowing and intentional conduct. The bill does not require platforms to monitor all content, remove material, or create a reporting or review process.
  • Parents and legal guardians: If a minor is depicted in or exposed to material through a platform’s violation, a parent or guardian could bring a civil case. The bill does not require a criminal conviction first.
  • People who possess or view material: The amended criminal provision prohibits knowingly possessing and intentionally retaining, or knowingly or intentionally accessing and intentionally viewing, specified images involving a minor. The bill also keeps an affirmative defense for promptly and in good faith taking reasonable steps to destroy the images or reporting them to law enforcement.
  • Attorney General: The Attorney General may seek an injunction or other equitable relief to enforce the platform rules; the bill does not require the Attorney General to bring a case.
  • General public: The bill creates no direct public benefit or front-line service. It adds civil and criminal legal rules.

Money#

No public cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill authorizes civil damages and legal costs, but does not set a public payment or fee.
  • It authorizes Attorney General enforcement but provides no staffing or spending estimate.
  • The displayed criminal fines are up to $2,500 for a first conviction under the section and up to $10,000 for a person previously convicted under it.

What is unclear#

  • “Minor” is not defined in the bill text. The exact age covered by the criminal-law change is therefore unclear from the supplied material.
  • The definition of “child pornography” points to another Criminal Law section whose text was not supplied. The full scope of that term could not be checked.
  • The bill does not explain how its “online platform” definition interacts with the service-provider exemption, or who else could be jointly and severally liable with a platform.
  • It sets no civil-case procedures, timelines, or special rules for deciding whether a platform knowingly and intentionally violated the ban.
  • The parent Acts were not supplied, so the full current-law baseline and the complete effect of the amendments could not be verified.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to cover AI-generated images that look like images of actual, identifiable minors, as well as to extend the criminal provision beyond the current wording referring to children under 16.
  • A civil action could give a parent or guardian a way to seek relief without waiting for a criminal conviction.
  • The Attorney General could seek court orders to stop violations, while the service-provider exemption limits coverage for entities that only transmit or store others’ communications and do not help create the material.

Case against#

  • The civil rules cover a wide range of online platforms and types of material, but key terms and how the rules apply to particular services are not fully clear in the supplied text.
  • The bill allows substantial civil remedies, including punitive damages and attorney fees, without setting a separate process for assessing claims or damages.
  • The meaning of “minor” is central to the criminal-law change but is not defined in the bill.
  • The bill authorizes enforcement and creates potential costs for lawsuits, but provides no estimate of public staffing or other costs.