Recall process for city officers

Summary#

H-5715, titled An Act providing for the recall of elected officers in the city of New Bedford, would create a local law setting out a process to recall the city’s elected officers. Its stated goal is to let registered voters remove an elected officer before the end of the officer’s term; the bill is introduced and is not yet law.

  • Voters would start a recall by filing an affidavit: at least 1,800 city voters for an at-large officer, with at least 300 from each ward, or at least 300 voters from the ward that elected a ward officer.
  • After the Board of Election Commissioners certifies the affidavit, petition forms must be returned within 45 days. They need signatures from at least 15% of registered voters in the city or relevant ward; for an at-large officer, at least 10% of the petition signatures must come from each ward.
  • If the signatures are certified, the City Council must notify the officer. Unless the officer resigns within five days, the council must order an election, usually 45 to 70 days after receiving the certified petition.
  • A majority of votes cast must favor recall, and at least 15% of the city’s or ward’s registered voters must vote in the recall election. The officer stays in office until the election results are certified.
  • A recalled officer could not run or be appointed to fill the vacancy created by that recall. The city charter would govern how the vacancy is filled.

What it means for you#

  • New Bedford voters: You could sign an affidavit and petition to seek a recall, subject to the thresholds, deadlines and ward requirements above. A recall would not happen just because enough people signed: a recall election must be held, and the turnout and vote requirements must both be met.
  • Elected officers: You could face a recall petition after your first four months in office. If you face a recall election and are not recalled, another recall petition could not be filed against you for the rest of your term. No recall election could be held if fewer than eight months remain in your term when the petition forms are certified.
  • City election officials and council: The Board of Election Commissioners would have to check signatures and certify petitions within set deadlines. The City Council would have to give notice and, unless the officer resigns, order the election. The council may delay it to another city election if one is scheduled within 90 days.
  • The public: The supplied material does not include current city recall rules or the city charter, so it does not establish how this process would differ from current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost.

  • The bill assigns petition-certification work to the Board of Election Commissioners and election-notice and scheduling duties to the City Council, but gives no cost estimate or funding.
  • It does not set a fee, fine or payment for voters or candidates.

What is unclear#

  • The bill requires a statement of the “grounds for recall” but does not define what grounds qualify or set a process for deciding whether they are sufficient.
  • The supplied material does not include current New Bedford law or the city charter, so existing recall rules and the process for filling a vacancy cannot be compared or described.
  • The bill does not say how recall-election costs would be paid.
  • The bill does not explain how the signature requirements would be applied if the number of registered voters changes after the most recent regular city election.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives voters a way to remove an elected officer before the next regular election.
  • The signature thresholds, limited time to collect signatures, minimum election turnout and ban on repeated recall attempts in the same term could help ensure a recall has meaningful support.
  • The officer would continue to serve unless they resign or voters meet the bill’s recall requirements.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define acceptable grounds for recall or provide a process to assess them, leaving an important part of the system unclear.
  • One concern is that petition review and election scheduling would add work for city officials, with no cost estimate or funding plan in the supplied material.
  • The 15% turnout requirement means a majority voting for recall would not remove the officer if fewer than 15% of registered voters participate.