Recall elections for town officials

Summary#

The bill, “An Act providing for recall elections in the town of Arlington,” would amend Chapter 503 of the Acts of 1952, as amended in 2018. It would replace sections 36 through 44 with a recall process for Arlington’s elected officials; the stated goal is to provide for recall elections. The supplied material does not include the existing sections, so it is not possible to verify which parts would be new and which would carry over.

  • At least 50 registered Arlington voters could start a recall effort by filing an affidavit naming the official and office and giving grounds for recall. The bill sets no standard for what grounds qualify.
  • If the affidavit’s signatures are verified, the first 10 signers would receive formal petition sheets. They would have 20 days to file them with signatures from at least 20% of Arlington’s registered voters, measured when the affidavit was filed.
  • If the petition is certified, the Select Board would notify the official. If the official does not resign within five days, the board must order a recall election, generally 64 to 90 days after receiving the petition.
  • Voters would decide whether to recall the official and, if a majority vote for recall, choose a successor in the same election. The official could run for that position.
  • An official who is recalled, or resigns while a recall petition is pending, could not be appointed to a town office for two years.

What it means for you#

  • Arlington voters: You could sign an initial affidavit or petition and vote on a recall. A recall would not take effect just because a petition is filed: it would require a certified petition and a majority vote for recall.
  • Elected officials: You would remain in office until the recall election. If you are not recalled, you would serve the rest of your term and could face another recall, but not within three months after the election. You could run to succeed yourself.
  • Petition signers: The first 10 affidavit signers would be responsible for filing the formal petition sheets within 20 days.
  • Town Clerk, Board of Registrars and Select Board: The clerk would forward the affidavit, prepare and record petition sheets, and certify the petition to the Select Board. Registrars would verify signatures within 14 days. The Select Board would give notice and, if the official does not resign, arrange the election.
  • Candidates and voters: If a majority votes for recall, the candidate with the most votes for the office wins. If fewer than a majority vote for recall, candidate votes are not counted. Multiple recalls could appear in one election, but each would have a separate ballot.
  • General public: This is a proposed town-specific election process. It does not itself create a new town office or organization.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of running recall elections.

  • The bill assigns election-related tasks to existing town officials but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • It does not set a fee or provide a funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of Chapter 503 is not supplied, so the existing recall rules—and how much this bill changes them—could not be verified.
  • The bill requires a statement of grounds but does not define acceptable grounds or explain who assesses them.
  • It does not set out a process for challenging signature verification or the petition’s certification.
  • The Select Board sets the election date within the stated limits and may combine it with a town election scheduled within 100 days; the bill does not give criteria for those choices.
  • The supplied status fields say both “Senate concurred” and “Stage: Introduced.” They do not establish whether the bill became law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give Arlington voters a formal way to seek an early decision on whether an elected official should remain in office.
  • Requiring signatures from 20% of registered voters before an election could help ensure that a recall vote follows substantial petition support.
  • The official stays in office until voters decide, and a majority must favor recall for removal to take effect.
  • Voters could choose a successor at the same election, rather than leave the office vacant after a successful recall.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not define what grounds justify a recall, or explain how the stated grounds are assessed.
  • The 20% signature requirement may make a recall difficult to bring, while the bill does not describe a way to challenge a rejected or disputed petition.
  • The bill gives the Select Board a role in setting the election date, but does not explain how it should choose among dates when it has a choice.
  • Election administration could require staff and money, but the bill provides no cost estimate or funding.