Bill Addresses Sexual Penetration in Custody

Summary#

HB 6468 would amend the Michigan Penal Code’s first-degree criminal sexual conduct law, not create a separate offense called “sexual assault of an inmate.” Its stated aim, suggested by the bill title, is to allow corrections officers to be charged in cases involving sexual penetration of a person under Department of Corrections jurisdiction. The supplied text includes such a rule, but without the current version of the Act or visible amendment markings, it is not possible to tell what wording the bill would change.

  • The text says first-degree criminal sexual conduct applies when the other person is under Department of Corrections jurisdiction and the actor is a department employee, contractual employee, or volunteer who knows the person is under that jurisdiction.
  • The text also includes similar circumstances involving certain private-vendor, county, and facility employees, contractors, or volunteers.
  • A first-degree conviction under this section carries imprisonment for life or any term of years, subject to listed exceptions. The text also requires lifetime electronic monitoring.
  • The bill is introduced and is not law. If enacted, it would take effect 90 days after enactment.

What it means for you#

  • People under Department of Corrections jurisdiction: The text makes sexual penetration by a covered department employee, contractor, or volunteer a circumstance for first-degree criminal sexual conduct if the actor knows the person is under the department’s jurisdiction. This provision does not state that force or coercion must be used.
  • Corrections employees, contractors, and volunteers: The text includes these groups, but does not expressly use the term “corrections officer.” Because the current law was not supplied, it is unclear whether the bill would newly expose any of them to this charge or restate existing law.
  • Other people: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or general rules about sexual conduct outside the circumstances listed in the section.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The text requires lifetime electronic monitoring for a person convicted under this section, but provides no cost estimate.
  • It does not give a spending amount, staffing estimate, or estimate of any change in court or corrections costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text does not show which words are being added or removed. The current version of the Penal Code was not supplied, so the exact legal change cannot be verified.
  • The text names department employees, contractual employees, and volunteers, but does not expressly name “corrections officers.” It is unclear whether the bill adds coverage or only changes wording.
  • The text does not define “under the jurisdiction” or explain how that term applies in practice.
  • The bill does not set out a special process for investigating or bringing charges under this provision.
  • Passage is uncertain because the bill is introduced and not yet law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that sexual penetration involving someone under the department’s control should be treated as a serious abuse of a custodial relationship.
  • The text expressly includes department employees, contractual employees, and volunteers, and requires that the actor know the person is under the department’s jurisdiction.
  • First-degree classification would make the conduct subject to the serious penalties listed in the section, including lifetime electronic monitoring.

Case against#

  • The current law was not supplied, so readers cannot tell whether the bill adds a protection or repeats an existing rule.
  • The text does not require force or coercion for the listed Department of Corrections circumstance. A possible concern is that the bill’s scope and rationale are not explained in the supplied material.
  • The bill does not expressly name corrections officers, leaving uncertainty about whether it changes the law for that group.