Care workers face shorter disqualification periods

Summary#

HB 6402 would amend Michigan’s Adult Foster Care Facility Licensing Act. It changes how long some criminal convictions can disqualify a person from work involving regular direct access to adult foster care residents; its stated goal is not given in the supplied material.

  • For specified serious felonies, the text changes the waiting period before a person may be employed or contracted from 15 years to 10 years after completing the sentence, parole and probation.
  • For listed misdemeanors, it changes a general lookback period from 10 years to 5 years and sets shorter periods for some other misdemeanors, including 3 years or 1 year in specified cases.
  • The changes apply to adult foster care facility employees and independent contractors with regular direct access to residents or who provide direct services. Staffing agencies also have duties under the bill.
  • The bill retains criminal-history checks and restrictions for convictions of relevant crimes described in federal law. Facilities may conditionally employ someone while a check is pending only under listed conditions.
  • The bill takes effect 90 days after enactment and does not take effect unless HB 6400 and HB 6401 are also enacted. It is introduced and is not law.

What it means for you#

  • Applicants and contractors: Some convictions would stop disqualifying a person sooner than under the periods shown in the bill text. Other restrictions remain. For example, the bill keeps a 10-year period for other felonies.
  • Applicants with certain misdemeanors: The bill sets different periods by offense. It includes a 5-year period for specified offenses applying to people licensed, registered or otherwise authorized in a health profession; a 3-year period for specified other misdemeanors; and a 1-year period for certain drug, larceny or retail-fraud convictions tied to the person’s age at conviction.
  • Adult foster care facilities and staffing agencies: They must continue to conduct or obtain the required criminal-history checks and follow the hiring restrictions. The bill allows conditional employment only if its requirements are met, including supervision in most cases until the check confirms eligibility.
  • Residents: The bill changes some employment restrictions, but does not remove criminal-history checks or all conviction-based restrictions.
  • Current law comparison: The Adult Foster Care Facility Licensing Act is being amended, but the current Act was not supplied. The bill text shows the proposed wording changes; I could not verify all of them against current law.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not provide an estimate of public or private costs.
  • It says criminal-history check fees may be paid by the facility, staffing agency or individual, and allows a one-time system setup fee of up to $100 for staffing agencies. The supplied text does not establish whether these are changes from current law.
  • The bill may affect staffing or screening costs, but the amount is unknown.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text does not explain why the disqualification periods are changing or provide estimates of how many applicants would be affected.
  • Some offense categories and age-based exceptions are complex. The practical effect may depend on how a conviction is classified.
  • The current Act was not supplied, so it is unclear which check, fee and hiring procedures are existing rules rather than changes made by this bill.
  • The bill is tied to HB 6400 and HB 6401, but their contents were not supplied. The combined effect is therefore unclear.
  • No start date is available unless the bill is enacted; if enacted, it would start 90 days later.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a person’s eligibility would depend on how long ago certain convictions occurred, rather than barring employment for as long as the current periods shown in the bill text.
  • Shorter lookback periods for some misdemeanors could let more applicants qualify while preserving criminal-history checks and restrictions for specified offenses.
  • The bill keeps supervision and other conditions for conditional employment while a check is pending.

Case against#

  • One concern is that people with some serious felony convictions could become eligible after 10 years instead of 15, even for offenses involving violence, abuse, neglect or sexual conduct.
  • Shorter disqualification periods could reduce a safeguard for residents who may have direct contact with staff or contractors. The bill does not provide evidence about how that risk would change.
  • The different offense lists, time periods and age exceptions may be difficult for facilities and applicants to apply consistently.
  • The bill gives no cost estimate for screening or implementation, and its effect cannot be assessed fully without HB 6400 and HB 6401.