State Incentives Would Bar Other Aid

Summary#

HB 6478 would amend the Michigan Strategic Fund Act by adding a restriction on economic incentives provided by state departments and agencies. It would bar an agency from providing an incentive unless the recipient and its affiliates have not received, and will not receive, other economic assistance. The bill’s title indicates a goal of limiting recipients’ ability to receive certain government incentives; the bill is introduced and is not law.

  • The restriction would apply to the Michigan Strategic Fund and other state departments and agencies, and cover grants, loans, tax captures or abatements, and other economic benefits.
  • Before approval and annually during the incentive’s term, a recipient would have to provide an affidavit about other assistance and information needed to check compliance.
  • If the recipient or an affiliate receives prohibited assistance, or the recipient fails to provide required information or gives false information, the incentive must be repaid. Any unpaid amount would be owed to the state with interest.
  • The bill also adds an exception to the Michigan Strategic Fund’s existing list of powers to account for the new restriction.

What it means for you#

  • Businesses and other incentive recipients: To receive a covered state incentive, you and your affiliates would have to meet the bill’s condition on other government assistance and provide the required affidavit and information.
  • Recipients’ affiliates: An affiliate’s receipt of other assistance could trigger repayment by the incentive recipient. An affiliate is defined by control, including majority ownership or control of day-to-day operations.
  • State departments and agencies: They could not provide a covered incentive unless the bill’s conditions were met. They would prescribe the affidavit’s form and manner.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not directly change general tax rates or create a new benefit program. It does include tax captures and abatements within the incentives it covers.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • Agencies would have to receive affidavits and information; the bill gives no estimate of related administrative costs or staffing.
  • Recipients who trigger repayment would owe the incentive amount; unpaid amounts would accrue interest at the rate used for tax deficiencies.
  • The bill does not state how much incentive funding might be affected.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say what time period applies to the requirement that a person “has not received” other assistance, or clearly specify the period covered by “will not receive.”
  • “Other economic benefit” is not defined, so the range of assistance that could disqualify a recipient is unclear.
  • The text does not explain how the new rule applies to incentives already approved or being provided when the bill takes effect.
  • The bill does not set out a process for disputes, appeals, or deciding whether information is sufficient.
  • The supplied material does not include the full current Act or details of existing incentive programs, so I could not verify how the new rule would interact with current requirements.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would prevent a person and its affiliates from combining a state incentive with other government assistance.
  • Requiring regular affidavits and information could give agencies a way to check whether recipients meet the condition.
  • Repayment and interest could give recipients a financial reason to comply with the condition.

Case against#

  • The restriction covers assistance from federal, state, and local governments, and “other economic benefit” is broad. It could exclude applicants who receive public support from another source, even if that support serves a different purpose.
  • Because an affiliate’s receipt of assistance can require repayment of the incentive, a recipient could face a large repayment obligation based on an affiliate’s actions.
  • The bill does not clearly define the time period for the no-other-assistance condition or explain how agencies should resolve disputes, leaving important decisions open.