Ultrasound Required Before Abortion Pills

Summary#

House Bill 6483 would amend Michigan’s Public Health Code and add new sections; it is an introduced bill, not law. It would require certain health professionals to get a positive pregnancy test and verify by ultrasound that a fetus is less than 12 weeks’ gestational age before prescribing a “medical abortion” (a non-surgical abortion using a prescription drug). Its stated goal, as reflected in the bill title, is to set requirements for prescribing abortion medication.

  • The requirement would apply to licensees covered by the new sections and to advanced practice registered nurses with nurse practitioner or nurse-midwifery certification.
  • A “medical abortion” is defined as a non-surgical abortion using a prescription drug. The requirement does not cover surgical abortion.
  • The bill would make a violation a ground for professional discipline under the Public Health Code.
  • It would exclude violations of the new sections from the Code’s general misdemeanor penalty provision; it does not state a replacement criminal penalty.

What it means for you#

  • Covered health professionals: They could not prescribe a medical abortion for a patient who is or is presumed to be pregnant unless they receive a positive pregnancy test and verify by ultrasound that the probable gestational age is under 12 weeks.
  • Patients seeking a medical abortion: The bill would require both a positive test and an ultrasound before the prescription. It does not set out a process for arranging those tests or say what happens if the ultrasound cannot verify an age under 12 weeks.
  • People seeking a surgical abortion: The bill’s definition of “medical abortion” excludes surgical procedures, so this requirement would not directly apply to them.
  • Professional regulators: A violation would be added as a ground for discipline. The bill does not create a new regulator or set out a separate complaint or review process.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The bill requires testing and ultrasound verification before covered prescriptions, but gives no estimate of costs to patients, providers, or the state.
  • It does not appropriate money or set a fee or fine in the text supplied.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not specify who must conduct the ultrasound, what test methods qualify, or what “verifies” the probable gestational age.
  • It does not state whether any exceptions apply.
  • It does not set out timelines, documentation rules, or an appeal process for a disciplinary decision.
  • The supplied materials do not include the current text of the Public Health Code. I could not verify against current law how much of the amended disciplinary and penalty language is new.
  • The bill gives no start date. Its passage is uncertain because it is introduced but not law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to require confirmation of pregnancy and gestational age before a prescription for a medical abortion.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that requiring an ultrasound could give the prescriber information relevant to whether the patient is below the bill’s 12-week limit.
  • Adding violations to the grounds for professional discipline would place enforcement within the existing licensing system described in the bill.

Case against#

  • One concern is that requiring both a pregnancy test and an ultrasound may add steps, time, and cost before a prescription; the bill gives no estimate of those effects.
  • The bill does not explain what happens when an ultrasound cannot verify an age under 12 weeks, or whether exceptions are possible.
  • The bill adds a disciplinary ground but does not set out specific procedures for applying it, leaving important details unclear.
  • The bill excludes these violations from the general misdemeanor penalty provision but does not explain whether another penalty applies.