Emergency Rules Would Protect Some Patient Visits

Summary#

HB 6484 would amend sections of Michigan’s Public Health Code that govern state and local emergency orders during epidemics. The stated goal is to set limits on restrictions on visits to patients and residents in certain health care facilities. The bill is introduced and is not law; because the current sections are not supplied and the bill text is garbled, it is not possible to verify which of the listed rules are new.

  • The text would let the state health director or a local health officer restrict visits for up to 30 days after declaring that epidemic control is needed.
  • After that period, an order must not block or limit a patient representative from visiting a patient or resident with a cognitive impairment. Officials could still require reasonable safety measures and, under stated conditions, set visitation procedures.
  • An order that addresses visitation must direct a facility to allow the patient or a representative to name up to three visitors, and to limit visits during regular hours to one of those visitors at a time.
  • “Patient representative” includes a qualifying family member, a patient advocate, or someone named as attorney-in-fact under a power of attorney. The covered facilities include health facilities or agencies, assisted living facilities, and physicians’ private practice offices.

What it means for you#

  • Patients, residents and representatives: If the bill’s wording became law, a patient or representative could designate up to three visitors when an emergency order addresses facility visits. Only one designated visitor could visit at a time during regular visiting hours. After the first 30 days, a representative of a person with a cognitive impairment could not be barred or limited by the order, subject to permitted safety measures and procedures.
  • Health care facilities: An order addressing visitation would have to direct the facility to follow the designation and one-visitor-at-a-time rules. State officials must consult facilities before setting certain procedures; local officials have the same consultation duty for their procedures.
  • State and local health officials: They could still issue epidemic orders that prohibit gatherings and establish procedures. Their ability to restrict facility visits would be limited as described above.
  • Other patients and residents: The text’s protection against restrictions after 30 days applies specifically to people with cognitive impairments and their patient representatives. The bill text does not give the same protection to all patients and residents.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The text requires facilities to follow visitation directions in an order, but gives no estimate of related costs.
  • It does not state a new appropriation, fee, fine, or staffing amount.

What is unclear#

  • The current Public Health Code sections are not supplied, so it is unclear which listed rules would change and which already exist.
  • The supplied text has garbled wording and numbering, including a broken phrase in the visitation provision. That makes the exact proposed amendments uncertain.
  • The text does not set a process for designating visitors beyond listing the information the designation must include, or say how disputes would be handled.
  • “Reasonable safety measures” and when visitation procedures are “vital” are not defined.
  • The text does not give a start date for the bill’s changes. Its references to rules beginning June 1, 2023 do not establish when this bill would take effect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would preserve contact with a representative for a person with a cognitive impairment even during a prolonged epidemic emergency.
  • Allowing safety measures, such as screening, testing, scheduling, or visit limits, could let officials address health risks while keeping visits possible.
  • A list of up to three designated visitors could give patients or their representatives some choice while limiting the number of people visiting at once.

Case against#

  • The bill would allow visitation restrictions for the first 30 days, and its post-30-day protection is limited to representatives of patients or residents with cognitive impairments.
  • Officials could still impose safety measures and visitation procedures, but the text does not define key terms such as “reasonable.”
  • The one-visitor-at-a-time rule could limit visits even when a patient or resident has named several people.
  • Because the supplied text is damaged and the current law is not available for comparison, readers cannot tell with confidence how much the bill would change existing rules.