New Solar Agreements on Preserved Farms Barred

Summary#

HB 6486 would amend Michigan’s Natural Resources and Environmental Protection Act. Its title says it would require farmland to be withdrawn from the farmland and open space preservation program for commercial solar use; the supplied text’s exact rules on that point are not fully clear. The bill’s stated goal is reflected in its title, but the text does not guarantee a particular outcome.

  • The bill’s text says a development rights agreement cannot be amended to make a solar facility a permitted use after the bill takes effect.
  • It also says an owner may relinquish land from the program to build a solar facility, with a lien on the land under other sections of the Act. The text provided does not clearly say this withdrawal is mandatory.
  • The text includes conditions for solar facilities allowed under a development rights agreement, including a financial bond or letter of credit for decommissioning and returning land to farming.
  • It says the state must subordinate its interest in certain agreements or easements to a later mortgage, lease, or other interest, if the parcel and landowner meet stated conditions.
  • The bill is introduced and is not law. The supplied text appears to combine old and proposed wording, so the precise changes from current law could not be verified.

What it means for you#

  • Owners of farmland in the preservation program: The text says owners may relinquish land to build a solar facility. The bill title says withdrawal would be required, but the operative wording supplied does not clearly impose that requirement.
  • Owners seeking to keep farmland enrolled: The bill would bar amendments made after its effective date that would make a solar facility a permitted use under a development rights agreement.
  • Solar facility owners or operators: For a facility proceeding under the listed conditions, the text requires financial assurance for decommissioning and returning the land to agriculture. An electric provider may take responsibility for some conditions, and must maintain certain privately owned agricultural drains.
  • Eligible farm landowners seeking financing: The state must subordinate its interest to a later mortgage, lease, or other interest if the parcel has qualifying existing structures and the requesting owner is an individual essential to operating the farm.
  • The public: The bill does not create a new agency, tax, or direct public service in the supplied text.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill text requires financial assurance for decommissioning and restoring farmland for solar facilities proceeding under the listed conditions. A licensed professional engineer calculates the amount, which must be reviewed at least every three years or when the department considers it necessary.
  • No estimate is provided for the cost of this assurance, any state administrative work, or effects on public revenue.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text does not clearly show which words are existing law and which are proposed changes. The parent Act was not supplied, so the exact changes from current law could not be verified.
  • The title says withdrawal is required for commercial solar use, but the supplied operative text says an owner “may” relinquish land to build a solar facility. How these statements fit together is unclear.
  • It is unclear how the new ban on amending agreements would affect solar facilities already allowed under an amended agreement.
  • The supplied material does not give an effective date or explain whether pending requests would be affected.
  • No publicly available information on expected costs or how the state would administer the changes is included.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would prevent new amendments from allowing solar facilities on land protected by development rights agreements.
  • Requiring withdrawal from the preservation program for solar use could make the program’s agricultural purpose clearer.
  • The listed financial assurance and land-restoration conditions could help address the cost of removing a facility and returning land to agriculture.

Case against#

  • The mismatch between the title’s claim of required withdrawal and the text’s permissive “may relinquish” wording leaves a key rule uncertain.
  • The bill does not clearly explain what happens to existing solar agreements or applications already underway.
  • A ban on new amendments could limit landowners’ options, while the text does not explain how that limit would interact with existing rules or agreements.
  • The financial assurance requirement could impose costs on solar facility owners or operators, but the amount and effect are not estimated.