Buyer Notices Could Trigger Farm Tax Recapture

Summary#

Senate Bill 1229 would amend Michigan’s 2000 Agricultural Property Recapture Act; it would not create a new law. Its stated goal, as described by the bill’s title, is to provide for recapturing tax when certain agricultural property changes use. The bill is introduced, is tied to SB 1230, and would not take effect unless SB 1230 is enacted.

  • The bill defines a change in use to include a buyer filing a notice to rescind the agricultural property tax exemption before a sale, and giving a copy to the seller. If the sale does not close within 120 days of the notice, that filing does not count as a change in use under this rule.
  • In that notice-based case, the person who owned the property before the transfer owes the recapture tax. The tax is due when the transfer documents are recorded, and the register of deeds must not record them before it is paid.
  • For a change in use that makes the property no longer qualify as agricultural property, the owner at the time of the change owes the tax. The tax becomes a lien on the property until paid; the state treasurer may sue if it is unpaid after 90 days, and delinquent property can face forfeiture, foreclosure, and sale.
  • The tax applies only when statutory conditions are met, including a qualifying transfer after 1999, no taxable-value adjustment because of specified transfer exceptions, and a change in use after 2000.
  • The bill defines the “benefit period” as up to the seven years before conversion. Its “benefit received” measure uses local tax rates and the yearly difference between the property’s true cash taxable value and its taxable value under the property-tax law.

What it means for you#

  • Buyers: If you file the required notice before a transfer and deliver a copy to the seller, the bill treats the property as converted by a change in use if the sale closes within 120 days. The notice must use a form prescribed by the Department of Treasury.
  • Sellers and other prior owners: In that notice-based case, you would owe the recapture tax, and the transfer documents could not be recorded until it is paid. If the sale does not close within the 120-day period, this notice does not trigger conversion under the bill.
  • Owners changing the property’s use: If an assessor determines the property no longer qualifies as agricultural property, the owner at that time would owe the tax. If it remains unpaid, the bill provides for a lien and possible collection through a lawsuit or delinquent-property proceedings.
  • Local assessors, treasurers, and registers of deeds: The bill assigns roles in determining whether property has stopped qualifying, collecting or pursuing unpaid tax, and blocking recording in the notice-based case.
  • Other property owners and the public: The bill does not directly change general property-tax rates or create a new agricultural benefit program.

Money#

No cost or revenue estimate is in the available material.

  • The bill concerns recapture tax, but the supplied text does not include the Act’s section that sets the tax amount.
  • The bill defines a measure of the benefit over a period of up to seven years, but that definition alone does not establish the final tax amount.
  • No estimate is provided for government staffing, administration, or collection costs.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the Agricultural Property Recapture Act was not supplied. I cannot verify which provisions are new and which restate existing law.
  • The bill refers to definitions and transfer exceptions in Michigan’s General Property Tax Act, but that Act was not supplied, so their full scope could not be checked.
  • The supplied text does not show how the recapture tax is calculated under the Act’s tax-imposition section.
  • It is unclear what process applies if a buyer files the notice, the sale closes within 120 days, but the parties dispute whether the tax is due or how much is owed.
  • The bill is not yet law, and its start date depends on enactment of SB 1230.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would identify a point before a sale when recapture tax is due, rather than leaving the issue until after the property changes hands.
  • Requiring payment before recording in the notice-based case could make collection more certain.
  • The 120-day limit gives a notice-based trigger a time boundary: if the sale does not close in time, that notice does not count as conversion under this rule.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a buyer’s notice could make the seller responsible for the tax and prevent the transfer from being recorded until payment is made.
  • The bill does not explain how the parties would resolve a disagreement about the tax amount or the notice’s effect before recording.
  • Without the current Act and its tax-calculation section, it is unclear how much tax could be due or how much the bill changes existing obligations.