Deed theft civil suit proposed

Summary#

SB-1218 would amend Michigan’s Revised Judicature Act of 1961 by adding a civil cause of action for “deed theft.” The bill’s apparent goal is to let people harmed by deed theft sue for money; it does not state a separate goal or promise a particular result.

  • A person who is a victim of deed theft could sue the person who committed it in circuit court.
  • In that lawsuit, the victim could seek $5,000, three times their actual damages, and reasonable attorney fees.
  • The bill defines deed theft to cover taking, transferring, or encumbering title to residential or commercial property without the owner’s approval or knowledge, or through fraudulent or deceitful means. It lists examples including forgery and falsely claiming to be the owner or the owner’s representative.
  • The bill would take effect 90 days after it is enacted. It is introduced and referred to committee, so it is not law.

What it means for you#

  • Property owners: If you are a victim of conduct that meets the bill’s definition of deed theft, you could bring a civil lawsuit and seek the listed payments. The bill does not itself say that a deed or title would be reversed or corrected.
  • People accused of deed theft: If sued under this section, you could be ordered to pay the amounts the bill lists. The bill does not create a criminal penalty.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill creates a legal claim between a victim and the alleged deed thief; it does not create a state program or direct payment to property owners.

Money#

No public cost estimate is supplied in the available material.

  • The bill would allow a successful claimant to seek $5,000, three times actual damages, and reasonable attorney fees from the deed thief.
  • The bill does not appropriate public money. Any court workload or other public cost is not estimated.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the Revised Judicature Act is not supplied, so existing legal remedies and how much this bill would add to them could not be verified.
  • The bill does not define “victim,” “owner’s approval,” or “deceitful means.”
  • It does not set out filing deadlines, procedures, defences, or how this claim would interact with other legal remedies.
  • The bill does not explain whether or how a lawsuit under this section could change the property’s title.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would give victims a specific civil claim for deed theft rather than leaving the remedy unstated in this new section.
  • Allowing recovery of attorney fees could help a victim bring a lawsuit; the bill also allows recovery of three times actual damages.
  • The definition covers residential and commercial property and lists several kinds of alleged fraud, including forged documents and false claims of ownership.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill allows recovery of $5,000 as well as three times actual damages and attorney fees, without stating a cap on the total.
  • The definition is broad and includes terms the bill does not define, which could leave uncertainty about which disputes qualify.
  • The bill creates a money claim but does not explain how a victim could use it to correct or restore the property title.