Deed Fraud Would Not Uncap Property Taxes

Summary#

Senate Bill 1215 would amend Michigan’s General Property Tax Act. Its goal is to protect a property owner’s taxable value from an increase caused by a deed-fraud transfer while the owner seeks to correct the title. The bill has no separate short title in the supplied material, is at the introduced stage, and would not take effect unless SB 1217 also becomes law.

  • Starting December 31, 2027, a deed-fraud conveyance would not count as a “transfer of ownership” for property-tax purposes if the owner files the required affidavit with the local assessing office.
  • The affidavit must be filed within 30 days after the owner becomes aware of the fraud. It must include a sworn statement and any supporting documents available to the owner. One type of affidavit also requires the owner to file, or say they intend to file, a related affidavit with the county register of deeds within 30 days.
  • If an assessor learns through that affidavit that there was no ownership transfer, the assessor must immediately restore the taxable-value limit and correct official records. Corrected tax bills must be issued where the tax roll is held.
  • If a court later finds the transfer was not fraudulent, the property’s taxable value must be uncapped from December 31 of the year the transfer occurred, and a corrected tax bill must be issued.
  • The bill defines deed fraud to include an unauthorized instrument affecting title and later title documents derived from it, even if someone relying on those later documents acted in good faith.

What it means for you#

  • Property owners affected by deed fraud: The bill would give you a way to have an apparent transfer treated as no transfer for property-tax purposes while the affidavit protection applies. You must meet the filing conditions. An affidavit alleging fraud may not be filed for more than three subsequent tax years for the same purported transfer.
  • Property owners whose transfer is later found not fraudulent: The bill requires the taxable value to be uncapped from the year of the transfer, with a corrected tax bill.
  • Assessors and tax offices: They would have to act on qualifying affidavits, correct tax records, and issue corrected bills. The bill does not itself decide who owns the property or create a court process to correct title.
  • Other property owners: The bill does not directly change the general rule that a transfer of ownership can uncap a property’s taxable value.

Money#

No cost estimate is supplied. No publicly available information.

  • Assessors and tax offices would have to process affidavits and correct records and tax bills; the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Corrected bills could change the amount of property tax collected, but the materials do not estimate the effect or explain how any resulting overpayment would be handled under these amendments.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current Act as a separate document, so I cannot verify every change against the law now in force.
  • The bill refers to other laws for the register-of-deeds affidavit and court determination; those procedures are not supplied here.
  • The bill does not explain how an assessor should assess the evidence in an affidavit, or what happens if the assessor disputes it.
  • The bill text gives a start date for the deed-fraud provision, but no general effective date appears. Its effect also depends on SB 1217 becoming law.
  • The supplied materials do not explain how the affidavit limit of three subsequent tax years works alongside a longer title dispute.

Case for#

  • A deed filed without the owner’s authorization could otherwise lead to a tax-value increase before the title dispute is resolved. The bill offers a way to address that tax consequence in the meantime.
  • The bill directs assessors to correct records promptly once they are made aware of a qualifying deed-fraud affidavit.
  • Its definition covers later documents derived from the unauthorized transfer, including cases where a later recipient acted in good faith.

Case against#

  • The affidavit process could change tax records before a court has made a final decision. The bill does not set out a detailed process for testing disputed claims.
  • The protection is conditional and time-limited for one type of affidavit. Owners may face higher taxable values if the required filings are missed or the protection period ends.
  • If a court later finds there was no fraud, the bill requires an uncapping and a corrected tax bill. It does not explain how taxpayers would be notified of the possible future adjustment when they file an affidavit.