Solitary seclusion banned in schools

Summary#

SB-1223 would amend Michigan’s Revised School Code; it does not create a new law or agency. Its stated goal is to reduce and eventually eliminate seclusion and restraint in public schools while protecting pupils’ safety and dignity. The bill is introduced and is not law; the supplied text says it would take effect 180 days after enactment.

  • It would prohibit solitary seclusion in all circumstances. Other seclusion would still be allowed as an emergency measure under limits in the bill.
  • Emergency seclusion and physical restraint could be used only to address an emergency involving imminent risk of serious bodily harm, and not for punishment, staff convenience, or to replace staffing, training, or an educational program.
  • School districts, intermediate school districts and public school academies would have to adopt local policies by July 1, 2027. The Michigan Department of Education would update state guidance and set a limit for physical-restraint use.
  • Schools would have to report each use to school leaders and a pupil’s parent or guardian immediately, provide a written report within the earlier of one school day or seven calendar days, and take additional steps after repeated uses.
  • Schools would have to collect and analyze use data, report it to the department, and present an annual summary to their governing board. The department would publish redacted, combined data quarterly and could take compliance steps in certain cases.

What it means for you#

  • Pupils and parents or guardians: Solitary seclusion would be prohibited. Emergency seclusion and physical restraint would remain possible only under the bill’s conditions. Parents or guardians would receive immediate notice and a written report after each use, and schools would have to make reasonable efforts to debrief with them.
  • Pupils with repeated incidents: If a pupil is secluded or physically restrained more than twice in 60 school days, school personnel would have to conduct a root-cause inquiry, develop or revise a positive-behavior support plan, and create a written emergency intervention plan with the parent or guardian.
  • Public schools and their staff: Schools would have to train staff, document incidents, collect and report data, and follow new or updated local policies. The bill sets limits and required steps for extending seclusion or restraint beyond specified general time limits: 15 minutes for elementary pupils, 20 minutes for middle or high school pupils in seclusion, and 10 minutes for physical restraint.
  • School districts and public school academies: If the department determines a school is using seclusion or excessive physical restraint, it would have to send notice. After repeated quarters of excessive physical restraint, the department could request records, tour the school or monitor training, among other compliance steps.
  • The bill would not ban all emergency seclusion or physical restraint, and it does not directly change school admissions, curriculum or student benefits.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Schools would have to provide staff training and handle added documentation, reporting, data analysis and planning duties; the bill gives no cost estimate or staffing figure.
  • The department would have to update guidance, set use limits, collect and publish data, and may carry out compliance activities. The bill gives no estimate for those costs or a specific funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current consolidated Revised School Code, so it is not possible to verify which requirements are new and which already apply.
  • The supplied bill text appears to combine old and replacement wording in places. That makes some exact changes difficult to confirm.
  • The bill does not give the numerical physical-restraint limits the department must set, or explain how it must calculate them.
  • It does not specify the staff or funding needed to carry out the new duties.
  • The bill’s stated start date is 180 days after enactment, but it does not say when enactment might occur. Passage is uncertain because the bill is only introduced.

Case for#

  • The bill recognizes that seclusion and restraint can cause physical and mental harm, and that they can interfere with pupils’ access to education.
  • Restricting these measures to emergencies involving imminent risk of serious bodily harm could reduce their use for discipline, convenience or inadequate staffing.
  • Required reporting, data analysis and follow-up plans could help schools identify repeated incidents and work to prevent them.
  • The bill preserves a limited emergency option while adding safeguards such as observation, time limits and parent notice.

Case against#

  • Schools would take on more training, reporting, planning and data duties, but the bill does not provide a cost estimate or explain how schools would fund them.
  • Key limits would depend on department guidance and restraint-use thresholds that the bill does not specify.
  • The department could set limits and take compliance steps, but the bill does not spell out all details of how those decisions would be made.
  • Because emergency seclusion and physical restraint remain allowed, the bill would not eliminate the risks it identifies.