Therapy spaces replace solitary confinement

Summary#

Senate Bill 1193 would amend Michigan’s Corrections Code of 1953 by adding a new section. Its stated goal is to replace solitary confinement with therapeutic and de-escalation spaces in prisons. The bill is introduced and would take effect only if Senate Bill 1192 is also enacted.

  • The Department of Corrections must develop a plan for therapeutic and de-escalation spaces in all prisons, with help from a new committee inside the department.
  • If the director finds that a “qualified prisoner” has a well-established, documented pattern of physical assaults, any placement of that prisoner in solitary confinement must be in a therapeutic space.
  • A qualified prisoner in restrictive housing must get at least eight hours a day of meaningful time outside their cell, with listed opportunities for activities and human contact.
  • The Department’s Bureau of Health Care Services must create written policies for therapeutic spaces. The policies must include specified conditions and activities, unless a prisoner’s individual treatment plan directs otherwise.
  • The new committee must meet at least monthly. It must help develop the placement plan, review prison culture, and have access to people in extended placement and the facilities where they are held.

What it means for you#

  • People in restrictive housing: If you are a qualified prisoner in restrictive housing, the bill would require at least eight hours a day outside your cell for meaningful activities and interaction. It also preserves access to standard store orders and a standard number of SecurePak items.
  • People placed in therapeutic spaces: Department policies must cover cell temperatures, positive visual features, sensory activities, outdoor time, exercise, tablet and television access, and person-centered planning. An individual treatment plan may direct otherwise.
  • Families and people with relevant experience: The committee must include at least two family members directly affected by a prisoner’s solitary confinement, at least two people who have experienced solitary confinement—one from a men’s facility and one from a women’s facility—and other specified members.
  • The Department of Corrections: It must develop the placement plan and create the policies. The committee is part of the department, not a new independent agency.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not set a tax, fee, fine, or benefit.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Department to develop a plan, prepare policies, and support a committee that must meet monthly, but gives no cost estimate or funding amount.
  • It does not say how many staff members, if any, must be hired or reassigned, or what the work would cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill uses “qualified prisoner,” “therapeutic space,” and “extended placement” by referring to section 64a, which was not supplied. I could not verify those definitions or compare the bill with current law.
  • The bill does not set out how placements are decided, how long they last, or whether a prisoner can appeal a placement decision.
  • The bill does not explain how the Department will assess whether the eight hours outside a cell are “meaningful,” or how compliance will be checked.
  • It does not require the committee to publish reports or give it power to order the Department to make changes.
  • The bill gives no start date of its own in the supplied text. It also cannot take effect unless SB 1192 is enacted.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to reduce the harms of isolation while still allowing therapeutic placement for prisoners with a documented pattern of physical assaults.
  • Requiring substantial daily time outside the cell, with opportunities for activity and human contact, could make restrictive housing less isolating.
  • The required committee includes people with lived experience, family members, health professionals, advocates, and Department employees. That mix could bring different perspectives to planning and review.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain how the Department will decide who is a “qualified prisoner,” or how the placement plan will work in practice.
  • The required spaces, activities, policies, and monthly committee meetings may require staff or other resources, but the bill gives no cost estimate or funding plan.
  • The committee can assist and review, but the bill does not say it can require changes or what happens if the Department does not follow its advice.
  • The bill says the plan is meant to replace solitary confinement, but it also allows solitary confinement in a therapeutic space for some prisoners. The practical boundary between those arrangements is unclear.