Charity-care surcharge would fund hospital payments

Summary#

HF 5142 would amend Minnesota’s hospital-surcharge laws and add a charity-care payment program to state law. It would direct the hospital surcharge into a special revenue account and require the commissioner of health to pay eligible hospitals from that account. The stated goal is to support hospitals’ charity care; the bill does not guarantee a particular payment or result.

  • The surcharge in the bill is 1.56% of a hospital’s net patient revenue, excluding net Medicare revenue. The bill directs this money to the charity care account rather than the general fund.
  • The commissioner must run the program and pay each eligible hospital that applies, subject to the money available.
  • Eligible hospitals must be Minnesota-licensed, nonprofit hospitals that filed a Medicare cost report. Some hospitals, including long-term acute care hospitals and specified government hospitals, are excluded.
  • Payments are based on the most recent year of available charity-care data. If funds are short, hospitals receive shares based on their share of total charity-care adjustments.
  • Hospitals receiving payments must report information the commissioner needs to evaluate the program.

What it means for you#

  • Hospitals: The bill requires Minnesota hospitals other than specified exceptions to pay the surcharge. Eligible nonprofit hospitals could apply for payments; receiving one would require reporting to the commissioner.
  • Patients: The bill does not create a patient payment or a new right to charity care. It does not change who qualifies for a hospital’s charity care.
  • State government and taxpayers: The commissioner must administer the program. The surcharge revenue would be set aside for payments and administration rather than deposited in the general fund.
  • Status: The bill is introduced and is not law. Its proposed start date is July 1, 2026.

Money#

The bill directs hospital-surcharge revenue to a dedicated account, but provides no estimate of revenue, payments, or total program cost.

  • The stated surcharge is 1.56% of net patient revenue excluding net Medicare revenue. The bill’s wording retains that rate; the materials do not establish whether the rate itself would change from current law.
  • Money in the account is appropriated each fiscal year for hospital payments and administration. The administration amount is left blank in the bill.
  • The bill gives no estimate of staffing or other administrative costs, or of how much hospitals would receive.

What is unclear#

  • The current version of the parent statutes was not supplied, so the exact change from current law—including how the surcharge is now handled—could not be verified.
  • The bill says charity-care adjustments must be converted to cost basis, but its payment formulas refer to charity-care adjustments without clearly stating whether each formula uses the converted or unconverted figures.
  • The bill does not set application deadlines, payment decision timelines, or an appeal process. It leaves the application and reporting forms and methods to the commissioner.
  • It does not set a dollar cap for administration or explain how the program would operate if the account did not have enough money for all payments.
  • The bill refers to a definition of charity-care adjustments in Minnesota rules, but those rules were not supplied.

Case for#

  • A dedicated account could make surcharge revenue available for hospital charity-care payments rather than general-fund spending.
  • A possible argument for the formula is that it links payments to hospitals’ reported charity care and shares limited funds in proportion to that care.
  • The commissioner would have to make payments at least once per fiscal year, giving eligible hospitals a regular payment schedule.

Case against#

  • Payments depend on the amount in the account, so the bill does not ensure that hospitals will be fully paid for their charity care.
  • The bill limits eligibility to certain nonprofit hospitals and excludes other named categories; it does not explain why those boundaries were chosen.
  • The unclear cost-basis calculation could affect how payments are divided.
  • The bill leaves the administrative appropriation blank and does not set key application, review, or appeal rules.