Judges could require money for release

Summary#

HB 3481 would amend Missouri Supreme Court Rule 33.01, which governs release conditions in criminal cases. Its apparent goal is to give judges more discretion to choose monetary or non-monetary conditions; that is not a guaranteed result. The bill has been introduced and, if enacted, would take effect January 1, 2027.

  • For a person charged with a bailable offense, release would still generally start with release on their own recognizance (a promise to return), unless the judge finds that this would not secure court appearances or protect people.
  • Judges would have to give substantial weight to the person’s prior convictions or history of criminal activity, prior failures to appear, the nature and seriousness of the charge, and known safety risks.
  • Judges would not have to try non-monetary conditions first before setting a monetary condition, if they find money is necessary to reasonably assure appearances and protect safety. The rule would still require the least restrictive condition, or combination of conditions, that is necessary.
  • The rule lists possible conditions including supervision; limits on travel, association or residence; reporting; electronic monitoring, testing and ignition interlocks; employment or education; curfews; weapon and substance restrictions; treatment; and return to custody for set hours. It also lists monetary, surety, cash, securities and property bonds, and other necessary conditions.
  • If no combination of conditions can secure safety, the court would still have to order detention based on clear and convincing evidence. The existing text also provides a trial-within-120-days right after a detained defendant’s written request after arraignment, subject to the stated rules about continuances.

What it means for you#

  • People charged with crimes: The bill does not remove the stated right to release for people charged with bailable offenses. But a judge could set a monetary condition without first trying non-monetary ones. The bill removes the current wording that expressly requires considering ability to pay before setting a monetary condition and bars an amount greater than necessary.
  • Judges: They would have broader discretion in choosing conditions, and their decisions would be presumed valid on review unless there is a clear abuse of discretion. They must still choose conditions no greater than necessary and consider the listed factors.
  • People ordered to use monitoring: The rule allows courts to make an eligible defendant pay all or part of electronic-monitoring costs. Courts must consider minimizing those costs and waive them for an eligible defendant who is indigent and shows an inability to pay.
  • People who are detained: The bill retains a right to a release hearing if a detained person cannot comply with a release condition. At Rule 33 hearings, the parties may—but do not have to—make a record about the person’s finances and ability to pay.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill contains no stated public spending amount or estimate of court or government costs.
  • Courts may order eligible defendants to pay some or all costs of electronic monitoring, with the stated cost-minimizing and waiver requirements. The bill does not estimate these costs.
  • Monetary bond conditions could require a defendant to promise payment, provide sureties, deposit cash or securities, or provide a property bond. The bill gives no estimate of the financial burden.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current rule as a separate text, so it is not possible to verify every change against the rule now in force. The bill’s marked deletions show that it removes the prior requirement to consider non-monetary conditions first and the express ability-to-pay limit on monetary conditions.
  • The bill does not explain how judges should weigh the four factors or what evidence is enough to find a monetary condition necessary.
  • “Eligible defendant” is not defined in the supplied text.
  • The bill does not specify how often courts would set monetary conditions, monitoring costs, or how many defendants might be affected.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that judges could tailor release conditions to the individual case and give substantial weight to past failures to appear and known safety risks.
  • Allowing monetary conditions without first exhausting non-monetary options could give judges another way to address concerns about court appearances or safety.
  • The least-restrictive-condition requirement and the clear-and-convincing-evidence standard for detention remain in the text.

Case against#

  • One concern is that removing the express ability-to-pay limit could lead to monetary conditions that a defendant cannot afford, even though ability to pay remains among the factors in the broader release decision.
  • The bill allows judges to set monetary conditions without first trying non-monetary ones, and gives substantial weight to the seriousness of the charge and criminal history. The practical effect of that change is unclear.
  • A possible trade-off is that decisions would receive limited review: the bill says they are presumed valid unless there is a clear abuse of discretion.